Skip to main content

ITS can only progress at the speed of public acceptance

The ITS sector is one of the younger and more dynamic industries in the economy and I am lucky enough to take the helm of ITS International at a point where the industry is in one of its most interesting phases. The technology is both established enough to show proven results and yet young enough to not fully know what the end game will be. It does not have the uniformity usually seen in older industries, while at the same time the bene ts are there – even if they are not always immediately evident to poli
May 24, 2013 Read time: 4 mins
The ITS sector is one of the younger and more dynamic industries in the economy and I am lucky enough to take the helm of ITS International at a point where the industry is in one of its most interesting phases. The technology is both established enough to show proven results and yet young enough to not fully know what the end game will be. It does not have the uniformity usually seen in older industries, while at the same time the bene ts are there – even if they are not always immediately evident to politicians or the public.

Accepting for a moment that the case for the adoption of ITS has been made, the industry needs to ask itself ‘where do we want to get to?’ Many see autonomous vehicles as a goal and as 1691 Google and others have shown, much of the technology already exists to enablethat, but the reality of a world full of vehicles that drive themselves may not be as utopian as many might imagine. Would vehicles be sent on empty journeys to pick somebody up from the railway station/ airport or school? And if so, those vehicles could cause additional congestion which would be of no concern to the vehicle owner who may be miles away, but would cause increasing problems for local inhabitants, cars with drivers and other road users. Then there is the problem of what happens if an autonomous vehicle is involved in an accident and the potential for misuse by individuals with less than honourable intentions.

More immediately, public expenditure in many regions, states and countries is being cut back and politicians are under increasing pressure to deliver results to the daily lives of the electorate. While for many reasons ITS may not be the public’s favourite technology, it has so much to offer in terms of lower costs, reduced pollution in cities, safer roads and increased utilisation. The latter point will become critical as 62 IBM’s Gerry Mooney highlighted at a meeting during 560 ITS America. He said that to cope with the expected increased in GDP between now and 2030, some $23 trillion of capital expenditure would be spent around the world on transportation systems. With many national and local authorities under tight budgetary constraints, accommodating the additional traffic that an enlarged economy will generate will be dif cult. However he recognised that the application of ITS can double or even triple the utilisation of the existing infrastructure at a cost far lower than building new roads.

And yet it seems many ITS initiatives – even those that appear to have no downsides - are running into dif culties and those can come from politicians, commercial interests or even the public.

As it is likely that most decisions will be made, or guided by, politicians, the only thing that really counts is what the public thinks and consequently how they will vote. That being the case, winning public approval is closely equated with winning political approval. Unfortunately the public often see the negative side of ITS – speeding tickets and road tolls rather than safer roads and free- owing highways.

Yet by their very nature almost every ITS system will create data that will show bene ts of the system - be that safety (fewer accidents or speeding offences) or ef ciency (shorter traffic queues, faster journey times). Where such evidence exists it is in the interest of the local authority and the politicians that it be disseminated to the local electorate - and local papers love a feelgood story. Collectively, these stories will win over even the most sceptical public for individual projects and by extension acceptance for the wider ITS industry. And where the public goes, politicians will inevitably follow. So there are many debates to be had and decisions to be made at local, national and international levels.

While these debates may ultimately fall to politicians, it is vital that they are informed by organisations and individuals from within the ITS industry. And as an ITS professional, that means you.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Robust enforcement strategy needed for free flow toll roads
    January 10, 2012
    Timidity has no place in effective enforcement operations on free-flow toll roads, says the NRA's Cathal Masteron. What's needed is a robust strategy which starts big and reduces in size over time, rather than starts small and gains a reputation for being easy to avoid
  • ITS industry needs more effort to get to the future
    January 19, 2012
    Eric Sampson, visiting professor at Newcastle University and City University London and ambassador for ITS-UK, provides a retrospective on the last couple of decades and takes a look at what the ITS industry still needs to do to get to where it needs to be
  • Carrots are proving cost-effective in Netherlands
    October 3, 2018
    There are lessons to be learned from congestion avoidance schemes in the Netherlands. David Crawford welcomes some new thinking in road pricing. Highway operators worldwide are being urged to learn from Dutch experience in using financial carrots rather than sticks to encourage drivers to avoid contributing to congestion. A Netherlands/UK group makes a convincing cost/benefit case in a new global survey of road pricing technologies, economics and acceptability. Representing the Rijkswaterstaat section of
  • Felix Scheuter, of Haenni Instruments, on effective highway weight enforcement
    September 26, 2013
    Felix Scheuter, managing director at Haenni Instruments, the renowned Switzerland-based mobile scales manufacturer, gives World Highways his views on how best to ensure effective highway weight enforcement The main danger for any road is its gradual destruction by overloaded heavy goods vehicles (HGVs). The more frequently such vehicles use a highway, the faster it is destroyed. Mobile patrol teams using mobile weighing scales are a highly effective way to enforce weight limits aimed at protecting ro