Skip to main content

Reliability is key to AV acceptance, finds Dutch study

Reliability is the key factor in people’s acceptance of autonomous vehicles, suggests a new academic study. Nine out of ten people said it was easy to use 2getthere’s Parkshuttle, operated by the Dutch municipality of Capelle aan den Ijssel. Four out of five respondents said the system - which connects Rivium business park and metro station Kralingse Zoom - is reliable, mainly because of its frequency and punctuality. The qualitative study from Utrecht University also focused on operational factors
August 31, 2018 Read time: 2 mins
Reliability is the key factor in people’s acceptance of autonomous vehicles, suggests a new academic study. Nine out of ten people said it was easy to use 8172 2getthere’s Parkshuttle, operated by the Dutch municipality of Capelle aan den Ijssel.


Four out of five respondents said the system - which connects Rivium business park and metro station Kralingse Zoom - is reliable, mainly because of its frequency and punctuality.

The qualitative study from 5584 Utrecht University also focused on operational factors include safety and security, travel time, information services, price and payment system, comfort and integration in the public transport network.

The author, by Jochem van der Burg, hopes that the insights gained could be used in the decision-making process around autonomous transit systems elsewhere.

When it came to safety, ParkShuttle passengers felt criminal activity on the vehicles was very unlikely - despite the absence of an on-board steward.

These findings, according to Van den Burg, contrast with passengers in a similar demonstration in Vantaa, Finland, who provided a low score for security – even though their AV was manned.

The disparity could stem from Parkshuttle’s larger passenger capacity of 24 which results in more “social control” when measured against the limit of ten riders per trip in the Finnish driverless bus.

Robbert Lohmann, CCO of 2getthere, believes it is also important that the Utrecht University study was based on a service which has been operational since 2006.

“Finnish respondents were asked for their impressions after a ride in a temporary demonstration, meaning their response is more likely based on expectation than actual experience,” Lohmann adds.

The Dutch study also shows only half of the riders feel positive about the travel information provided at stations - and nearly all say there is a lack of information about delays and cancellations.

Going forward, 2getthere intends to install information kiosks at shuttle stops to display system status and the vehicle’s arrival time. ParkShuttle’s current single information displays will be replaced by two 19” vertical touch screens which will display information on travel time.

Related Content

  • March 4, 2019
    Transport Systems Catapult boss: ‘We can’t build our way out of congestion’
    The UK Transport Systems Catapult’s CEO Paul Campion talks to Colin Sowman about helping companies develop tomorrow’s solutions – and explains why you can never build your way to empty roads The future of mobility is going to be driven by services.” That’s the opening position of Paul Campion, CEO of the Transport Systems Catapult (TSC) – the UK government organisation set up to help boost transport-related employment and the economy. Campion was previously with IBM and describes himself as a ‘techno o
  • October 7, 2019
    Driven demos AVs operating ‘safely’ in London
    The Driven Consortium has completed a week-long demonstration which it says shows that autonomous vehicles (AVs) can operate safely in London - with a safety driver. Driven - a £13.6 million initiative supported by the UK government - carried out the demo around Queen Elizabeth Olympic Park in Stratford in the east of the city. Driven has focused on completing fully-autonomous routes within the UK capital and the city of Oxford using Oxbotica’s autonomous software. Consortium members Moninet and Axa XL p
  • July 23, 2019
    San Francisco bans facial recognition
    San Francisco has become the first US city to ban facial recognition software – and it is a move which has implications for transit agencies as well as police forces worldwide Big Brother is watching you’, goes the famous saying. Well, not in San Francisco he isn’t. Legislators in the Californian city – home to the tech gold rush and embracers of all things forward-looking – have decided that, after all, there should be limits to technology’s hold over us. By a margin of eight votes to one, the city’s
  • July 4, 2019
    Lack of funds holding back smart cities, says Wi-Sun
    Lack of investment is the biggest challenge to smart city development, according to half the people who took part in a poll. Wi-Sun Alliance says a fifth of participants in its survey point to security and privacy issues while 14% see interoperability as a major factor for progressing deployments. Wi-Sun – whose members include Cisco and Toshiba - seeks to accelerate the implementation of open standards-based field area networks and the Internet of Things (IoT). Phil Beecher, CEO of Wi-Sun, says