Skip to main content

New York to start congestion charging 'from January 2025'

Final approval for delayed scheme still required as $15 toll lowered to $9
By Adam Hill November 15, 2024 Read time: 2 mins
Big Apple: finally taking a bite out of congestion? (© Brett Critchley | Dreamstime.com)

New York City's congestion charging scheme - which was put on hold earlier this year by New York state governor Kathy Hochul - is now back on the agenda.

As New York City Metropolitan Transportation Authority (MTA) puts it: "The Central Business District Tolling Program has been unpaused."

The MTA board and Federal Highway Administration still need to officially approve the scheme - whose purpose is to reduce congestion, improve air quality and provide funds for public transportation. 

From 5 January 2025, the proposed daily charge will be $9 to enter the congestion charge zone which covers parts of Manhattan - down from the $15 which was originally proposed.

Hochul says that the 40% decrease "saves an average daily commuter $1,500 per year".

"Lower-income New Yorkers will see even more savings: a 50% discount after the 10th toll of the month. If it's after 9pm, the toll will be reduced further."

Not everyone agrees with Hochul's about-turn.

Transportation and Infrastructure Committee chairman Sam Graves, and New Jersey governor Phil Murphy, are particularly unimpressed.

“President-elect Trump has made it clear that he does not support this congestion pricing scheme, and the rush to institute it before he can take office is a blatantly political move," Graves wrote in a statement.

"This calculated decision flies in the face of the message Americans just sent, and my committee will consider all options to conduct the necessary oversight of this issue as we move forward.”

Meanwhile, Murphy wrote: “I am firmly opposed to any attempt to force through a congestion pricing proposal in the final months of the Biden Administration. All of us need to listen to the message that voters across America sent last Tuesday, which is that the vast majority of Americans are experiencing severe economic strains and still feeling the effects of inflation. There could not be a worse time to impose a new $9 toll on individuals who are traveling into downtown Manhattan for work, school, or leisure."

On the X social media platform, Hochul wrote: "New York is moving forward with congestion pricing & a plan that strengthens public transit while putting commuters first."

"This lower toll allows us to accomplish all the goals of congestion pricing: modern signals, the Second Avenue subway, new electric buses, elevators, improvements for @MetroNorth [Metro-North Railroad] & @LIRR [Long Island Rail Road], less gridlock, cleaner air - all while lowering costs for New Yorkers."

Hochul added: "Our plan funds the MTA, reduces congestion, & keeps millions of dollars in the pockets of commuters. I look forward to seeing it take effect this January."

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Birmingham embraces e-scooter 'impact'
    October 18, 2022
    Rides in UK city replace 680,000 'unnecessary' car journeys, micromobility company insists
  • Cost benefit analysis ‘can’t be carried out with a cookbook’
    June 25, 2018
    There is far more to working out the worth of a project than simply filling in a few headings on a spreadsheet. David Crawford surveys some recent thinking from the US and Canada. Cost benefit analysis (CBA) “can’t be carried out with a cookbook”, warns US analyst Professor Robert J Brent. “ You can’t just get out a spreadsheet and fill in the data for all the headings. Each transport CBA should have something that is distinctive, in terms of location (for example, for a rural area), types of user
  • How digital navigation is key to managing congestion
    March 24, 2023
    Satnav – not costly civil engineering projects – might point us towards better management of congested road networks, argues David Metz of University College London
  • Authorities look to MaaS for new solutions and cost savings
    July 18, 2017
    The structure of society and the way in which our cities work will be completely transformed by Mobility as a Service (MaaS), Finland’s minister of transport and communications Anne Berner, told ITS International’s recent MaaS Market conference 2017 in London. In her keynote address, Berner told a packed audience of more than 200 ITS professionals that MaaS has the potential to help governments around the world meet their big city targets such as the rate of employment, the environment, the efficient use of