London’s zero-emission plan is premature, warns FTA

Plans to implement a clean air zone in London are premature, says a transport trade body - because zero-emission vehicles are not commercially viable. The Freight Transport Association (FTA) is unimpressed with the City of London Transport Strategy’s ambition to improve air quality and traffic in the east of the capital and the Barbican area by 2022. This draft scheme, which maps out a 25-year framework for managing streets within the City’s ‘Square Mile’, includes establishing a speed limit of 15 mp
October 24, 2018 Read time: 3 mins
Plans to implement a clean air zone in London are premature, says a transport trade body - because zero-emission vehicles are not commercially viable.


The 6983 Freight Transport Association (FTA) is unimpressed with the City of London Transport Strategy’s ambition to improve air quality and traffic in the east of the capital and the Barbican area by 2022.

This draft scheme, which maps out a 25-year framework for managing streets within the City’s ‘Square Mile’, includes establishing a speed limit of 15 mph, with road closures to prioritise pedestrians at peak times and time restrictions on deliveries. The project is expected to reduce overall motor traffic by 25% by 2030 and 50% by 2044.  

However, Denise Deedell, policy manager for vans and urban transport at FTA, says greater investment is needed to develop zero-emission vehicles. The first problem, she insists, is that the purchase price of electric vehicles needs to be reduced to become an affordable and realistic option for businesses of all sizes.  
“Secondly, there is insufficient charging infrastructure in place. While FTA notes the proposals include a potential charging hub, a nationwide infrastructure strategy is needed for its long-term feasibility,” Deedell adds.

Deedell believes the capital needs a coordinated approach to air quality and road traffic schemes - rather than what she describes as a ‘patchwork’ approach adopted by London’s Hackney Council last month.

Under this %$Linker: 2 Internal <?xml version="1.0" encoding="utf-16"?><dictionary /> 4 36559 0 link-external initiative false /sections/general/news/petrol-diesel-cars-could-be-fined-for-using-londons-electric-streets/ false false%>, petrol and diesel drivers could be fined £130 on nine ‘electric’ roads in Shoreditch and Old Street between 7am-10am and 4pm-7pm on weekdays.

Only ultra-low emission vehicles (ULEVs), which emit less than 75/kg of carbon dioxide, can use streets freely.

The project is funded by London mayor Sadiq Khan’s air quality fund along with the government’s Go Ultra Low City Scheme – a project set-up to help establish London as the ‘ULEV capital of Europe.’

FTA is also unhappy about “clean air zones of different sizes, start dates and charges being introduced across several UK cities”.

"This approach is confusing and unhelpful for logistics businesses and makes it challenging for them to put appropriate plans in place,” Deedell adds.

The final draft of the Transport Strategy will be submitted to the Planning and Transportation Committee for approval on 30 October along with the draft local implementation plan. If it goes ahead, a consultation on both documents will follow between November and January 2019. The final strategy will be submitted in March 2019.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Los Angeles launches own ‘Green New Deal’
    May 2, 2019
    The city of Los Angeles has released what it calls ‘LA’s Green New Deal’, pledging $860 million per year “to expand the transportation system”. Electric vehicles are at the fore: it pledges an $8 billion upgrade to the city’s electricity grid by 2022, to help build the US’s “largest, cleanest and most reliable urban electrical grid to power the next generation of green transportation”. The city authorities will “expand electric car sharing options” and support implementation of Metro’s first/last mile pl
    Read More
  • CILT urges policy review for London Mayor’s transport strategy
    October 4, 2017
    The Mayor of London’s Draft Transport Strategy (DMTS) lacks realism and risks unintended consequences, according to a report from the Charted Institute of Logistics and Transport (CILT). Proposals on bus priority require a fundamental review as speeds on a third of London’s bus routes have fallen more than 5% in the past year, including a reallocation of road space, construction works (with resulting congestion) and an increase in the volume of private hire and van traffic. CILT calls for bus corridors
    Read More
  • British Safety Council launches app for measuring air pollution in London
    March 11, 2019
    The British Safety Council (BSC) and Kings College London have launched an app for outdoor workers to measure exposure to air pollution – an increasing preoccupation for the ITS industry. The Canairy app could help improve workzone safety by providing employees, and their bosses, with information to help them reduce exposure to air pollution. The app is being launched as part of the BSC’s ‘Time to Breathe’ campaign, which seeks to encourage companies, policymakers and regulators to take the risks of
    Read More
  • UK well positioned to benefit from autonomous lorries, says Inrix
    September 24, 2018
    Driver shortage, commercially-viable roads and Brexit uncertainty position the UK to develop and benefit from autonomous freighting, says Inrix. The analytics company's latest report has identified the A1 from Sheffield to Edinburgh as the most suitable corridor for testing highly automated vehicles (HAV). The Inrix Automated Freight Corridor Assessment reveals the next best-suited corridor is the M5/A38 from Plymouth to Birmingham, followed by the M4 from Swindon to Swansea.
    Read More

Highlighted Content