Skip to main content

EU citizens ‘pay twenty times too much for traffic noise reduction’

According to Paul de Vos, strategic advisor at engineering and consultancy firm Royal HaskoningDHV, European policy forces local authorities to make huge investments in traffic noise reduction. Until 2017, European governments will be spending US$168 billion for noise barriers, quieter roads and measures related to the negative effects of traffic noise, including damage to health. However, by simply making cars quieter, the total cost to the taxpayer could be reduced by a factor of twenty.
November 8, 2013 Read time: 3 mins
According to Paul de Vos, strategic advisor at engineering and consultancy firm 6132 Royal HaskoningDHV, European policy forces local authorities to make huge investments in traffic noise reduction.

Until 2017, European governments will be spending US$168 billion for noise barriers, quieter roads and measures related to the negative effects of traffic noise, including damage to health. However, by simply making cars quieter, the total cost to the taxpayer could be reduced by a factor of twenty.

All the more remarkable, then, that no legislation is forthcoming, says de Vos, chairing a session on the subject at the Geluid, Trillingen en Luchtkwaliteit (Sound, Vibrations and Air Quality) congress in the Netherlands.
 
According to the 1819 World Health Organisation, 210 million European citizens (44 per cent of the EU population) are exposed to traffic noise and risks to their health on a daily basis. Says De Vos: “It makes perfect sense for governments to invest in measures to limit noise. However, it can be done much cheaper.”

A study by research organisation 7087 TNO shows that the cost of making road traffic quieter adds up to a total of US$168 billion of tax-payer money. According to TNO, making cars quieter would cost the industry US$9 billion. De Vos explains: “For the consumer it comes down to the choice: either to add US$27 to the cost of a new car, or pay an additional US$537 in tax for noise barriers and healthcare costs.”
 
The topic of noise limits for road vehicles was up for debate for the third time in Brussels, by three European institutions: the Parliament, the Council and the Commission. Dutch influence in the process is limited, De Vos recognises: “The Dutch government is subject to European regulations. In practice, the words of countries with large car industries carry the most weight in Europe. In addition, the car industry itself has a major voice in the discussion.”  De Vos fears that the talks will only result in muddling through with the current policy. The European sound norms date from 1970 and have been modified three times since then, but to limited effect due to the test methods being modified at the same time.
 
De Vos discussed how the actual standards will serve the public the most, saying: ‘It is time that the 210 million European citizens are given a voice in this debate.’

Related Content

  • Time for a rethink on road user charging
    February 1, 2012
    There is no value in further US VMT charging trials, except to delay the inevitable. These trials should end after completion of the University of Iowa's National Evaluation of a Mileage-based Road User Charge. There is far greater promise in unleashing private operators to commence profitable, non-tolling services, then using these for toll assessment and collection as fuel distributors are currently used to collect fuel taxation. Bern Grush writes
  • Road death toll increasing in poor countries, says WHO report
    February 20, 2019
    The latest figures from the World Health Organisation on road deaths make sobering reading – but they are particularly shocking when you consider how the relative poverty of countries contributes to high fatality rates, says Adam Hill Around 1.35 million people died on the world’s roads in 2016, while road traffic injuries are now the leading cause of death among young people, according to new statistics from the World Health Organisation (WHO). Perhaps the most sobering point from its latest research
  • RAC report - motorists frustrated with road taxes
    June 13, 2013
    According to the RAC’s 2013 Report on Motoring, the condition of the UK’s motorways and local roads, characterised by the now year-round problem of potholes, ranks as a top concern for motorists. While the cost of driving is understandably still the number one concern for nearly half (46 per cent) of Britain’s motorists, two in five (41 per cent) say maintenance of local roads and motorways is their top spending priority. In addition, 84 per cent of motorists believe their local roads are deteriorating and
  • PTV Group and TNO research institute to cooperate on urban mobility planning
    June 20, 2017
    PTV Group and TNO, The Netherlands Organisation for Applied Scientific Research, are to join forces to help cities resolve mobility, urban planning and environmental challenges, by combining PTV Visum and TNO Urban Strategy.