AV drivers need help for safe handovers, says RAC

Drivers will need help preparing for unexpected situations where their autonomous vehicle (AV) hands back control, warns the RAC Foundation. RAC carried out a study in the UK with the Human Factors Research Group at the University of Nottingham on 49 people of varying ages using a driving simulator on a ‘commute-style’ journey for five days in a row. During the trial, the drivers demonstrated significant lateral movement (lane swerving) when control was handed back to them, even after being provided
July 19, 2019 Read time: 3 mins

Drivers will need help preparing for unexpected situations where their autonomous vehicle (AV) hands back control, warns the 4961 RAC Foundation.

RAC carried out a study in the UK with the Human Factors Research Group at the University of Nottingham on 49 people of varying ages using a driving simulator on a ‘commute-style’ journey for five days in a row.

During the trial, the drivers demonstrated significant lateral movement (lane swerving) when control was handed back to them, even after being provided with advanced warnings. Around half of the participants had to look at the floor to check their feet were on the correct peddles when asked to retake control.

Despite this, the drivers were able to keep the vehicle straight when presented with an emergency handover on the fourth day involving severe weather. This could be because of the hyper-vigilance induced by the prospect of danger, RAC says.

Professor Gary Burnett, chair of transport human factors at the university, says steering performance immediately following a handover can be poor, indicating the importance of “new forms of training to equip drivers with the additional skills needed in these vehicles”.

“The results also highlight that any future automated vehicle that can be human-driven should incorporate appropriate technology to monitor how ready a driver is to resume control and assist them in this process,” Burnett adds.

Additionally, the trial set out to explore how participants may choose to spend their time after selecting the ‘automated driving’ option during the 20 minute dual carriageway section of the journey.

Eight out of ten drivers commonly used their smartphones while a quarter read books or newspapers at least once during the week. Others worked on laptops.

Those who looked away from the road while the vehicle was in autonomous mode increased from 70% on day one to 80% by day five, indicating an increase in trust by the end of the trial.

Steve Gooding, director of the RAC Foundation, says designers are going to have to “apply their minds” to circumstances where drivers will be invited or required to retake control if “conditionally-automated vehicles” are to be allowed on public roads.

“The very real likelihood is that, at best those motorists will need plenty of warning to set down their papers or close their laptop and, at worst, still more time to wake from slumber,” he continues. “Re-taking control of a speeding car is a dangerous task, and the idea of the human driver being available to take over in an emergency looks to be fraught with difficulty.”

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • IBTTA summit hits right notes in Salzburg
    December 5, 2018
    In the birthplace of Mozart, Colin Sowman found that delegates at the IBTTA’s inaugural World Tolling Summit were playing a variety of interesting tunes The first World Tolling Summit took place in Salzburg, Austria this autumn. Created and organised by the International Bridge Tolling and Turnpike Association (IBTTA), the event was supported by its European counterpart Asecap and hosted by Austria’s tolling authority, Asfinag. The transfer of views, experience and practice both ways across the Atl
    Read More
  • One in seven UK drivers would cross a level crossing illegally, says study
    October 5, 2018
    One in seven UK drivers would drive over a level crossing before the barrier or gate has opened, according to new research. Research agency Populus carried out a study on behalf of Network Rail which reveals six UK drivers have been killed at level crossings in the last five years. There are also around 46 incidents every week in the UK involving vehicles at level crossings – a third of which are caused by lorries, followed by cars at 28%. According to the report, one in nine drivers would go over a l
    Read More
  • Data collection becoming a crowded market
    October 26, 2017
    New ways of gathering data can revolutionise traffic and travel management, so is the writing on the wall for the traditional methods? Jon Masters reports. There are two big industries that stand to be revolutionised by massive increases in data – healthcare and transportation, says Finlay Clarke, the UK managing director of the smartphone sat nav traffic app, Waze. “At present we’re really only at the start of how cities, in particular, will be transformed,” he says.
    Read More
  • Cost benefit: just $25 boosts pedestrian safety in Florida
    April 29, 2019
    A relatively straightforward change to the way that pedestrians cross the street in a Florida city has made a significant safety improvement. And what’s more, it was cheap, finds David Crawford Installing a lead pedestrian interval (LPI) system at 25 central business district signalised intersections in the Florida city of Lakeland has cut numbers of incidents involving pedestrians by some 60% - at a cost of US$25 for 30 minutes' work, according to traffic operations manager Angelo Rao.
    Read More

Highlighted Content