AV drivers need help for safe handovers, says RAC

Drivers will need help preparing for unexpected situations where their autonomous vehicle (AV) hands back control, warns the RAC Foundation. RAC carried out a study in the UK with the Human Factors Research Group at the University of Nottingham on 49 people of varying ages using a driving simulator on a ‘commute-style’ journey for five days in a row. During the trial, the drivers demonstrated significant lateral movement (lane swerving) when control was handed back to them, even after being provided
July 19, 2019 Read time: 3 mins

Drivers will need help preparing for unexpected situations where their autonomous vehicle (AV) hands back control, warns the 4961 RAC Foundation.

RAC carried out a study in the UK with the Human Factors Research Group at the University of Nottingham on 49 people of varying ages using a driving simulator on a ‘commute-style’ journey for five days in a row.

During the trial, the drivers demonstrated significant lateral movement (lane swerving) when control was handed back to them, even after being provided with advanced warnings. Around half of the participants had to look at the floor to check their feet were on the correct peddles when asked to retake control.

Despite this, the drivers were able to keep the vehicle straight when presented with an emergency handover on the fourth day involving severe weather. This could be because of the hyper-vigilance induced by the prospect of danger, RAC says.

Professor Gary Burnett, chair of transport human factors at the university, says steering performance immediately following a handover can be poor, indicating the importance of “new forms of training to equip drivers with the additional skills needed in these vehicles”.

“The results also highlight that any future automated vehicle that can be human-driven should incorporate appropriate technology to monitor how ready a driver is to resume control and assist them in this process,” Burnett adds.

Additionally, the trial set out to explore how participants may choose to spend their time after selecting the ‘automated driving’ option during the 20 minute dual carriageway section of the journey.

Eight out of ten drivers commonly used their smartphones while a quarter read books or newspapers at least once during the week. Others worked on laptops.

Those who looked away from the road while the vehicle was in autonomous mode increased from 70% on day one to 80% by day five, indicating an increase in trust by the end of the trial.

Steve Gooding, director of the RAC Foundation, says designers are going to have to “apply their minds” to circumstances where drivers will be invited or required to retake control if “conditionally-automated vehicles” are to be allowed on public roads.

“The very real likelihood is that, at best those motorists will need plenty of warning to set down their papers or close their laptop and, at worst, still more time to wake from slumber,” he continues. “Re-taking control of a speeding car is a dangerous task, and the idea of the human driver being available to take over in an emergency looks to be fraught with difficulty.”

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • In-vehicle vision-based systems and autonomous vehicles
    January 11, 2013
    The Artificial Vision and Intelligent Systems Laboratory (VisLab) of Italy’s Parma University has built itself a fine pedigree in basic and applied research which has developed machine vision algorithms and intelligent systems for the automotive field. In 1998, a VisLab-equipped Lancia Thema named ‘Argo’ travelled along the famous Mille Miglia race route and completed 98 per cent of it autonomously using then-current technology. In 2005, VisLab provided the vision element of the Terramax, a collaborative un
    Read More
  • Safer roads need safe systems approach, better infrastructure
    January 19, 2012
    Some developed countries are far from leading the way when it comes to making road infrastructure safe. In fact, says the Road Safety Foundation's Joanne Hill, they learn a lot from what is happening in emergent nations. A new report from the Road Safety Foundation, 'Saving Lives, Saving Money - the costs and benefits of achieving safe roads', makes some startling assertions about attitudes to road safety. Although concerned predominantly with the UK, there are some universal lessons to be learned, accordin
    Read More
  • Big wheels keep on turnin’
    August 21, 2018
    Many of the great and the good in the global mobility sector gathered at this year’s Movin’ On event in Montreal. Measured regulation of technologies and safety issues were major themes, reports David Arminas. *Bibendum is the original name for the Michelin Man, the symbol of the Michelin tyre company Autonomous vehicles, platooning, smart intersections and safety – these were the talking points over two-and-a-half days of the Movin’ On event in Montreal, Canada. Everyone in the mobility sector is at the
    Read More
  • ITS needs to talk the talk as well as walk the walk
    March 24, 2014
    The US automated enforcement market is in rude health as the number of systems and applications continues to grow and broaden. Jason Barnes reports. Blessed and cursed – arguably, in equal measure – with a constitution which stresses the right to self-expression and determination, the US has had a harder journey than most to the more widespread use of automated traffic enforcement systems. In some cases, opposition to the concept has been extreme – including the murder of a roadside civil enforcement offici
    Read More

Highlighted Content