Skip to main content

Promoting EVs is not the answer to climate concerns, warns Cubic

Increase of cars will require more road-building which risks cancelling out carbon savings
By Adam Hill April 3, 2023 Read time: 2 mins
The right way to go? (© Ezthaiphoto | Dreamstime.com)

The UK government would be better pursuing transit-first policies as part of its green strategy, rather than focusing on electric vehicles (EVs).

That's according to Audrey Denis, strategy manager at Cubic Transportation Systems (CTS), in response to last week's green energy policies and decarbonisation commitments, intended to help meet climate change goals. 

“Making a sustainable vision a reality is easier said than done, especially when it comes to transportation," she says. 

"However, it's frustrating to see the UK’s new green strategy once again centre around electric vehicles - which bring a multitude of challenges in the pursuit of Net Zero."

Part of the UK’s ‘Green Day’ - the UK government’s response to the Biden-Harris administration’s Inflation Reduction Act in the US - was a £380 million commitment to grow the UK's EV charging network.

"While alternate fuel sources are important, even an electric vehicle is taking up valuable space on our roads, contributing to congestion," says Denis.

"The rapid increase of cars will require more road-building - which in itself will cancel out 80% of the carbon savings from a switch to electric over the next 12 years, analysis shows. If use of EVs reaches 80 % by 2050, this would also require an additional 150 gigawatts of electricity for charging them, which risks offsetting the positive climate impacts."

Pursuing transit-first policies is the best way to cut car dependency and shift travellers to public transit," Denis concludes.

"With the right tools, passenger behaviour can be changed – or ‘nudged’ – to make an impact on traffic and pollution."

Related Content

  • Fuel for Thought: The what, why and how of motoring taxation
    May 15, 2012
    The Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) has highlighted the dilemma facing many governments – motoring tax income set to fall even as traffic rises - in an analysis of the decline in the amount of revenue collect from fuel duty and VED (vehicle excise duty) in the UK. The collapse in income from motoring taxation will be caused by increasingly fuel efficient petrol and diesel cars, and the predicted large-scale take-up of electric vehicles.
  • Amazon pledges to meet Paris Agreement 10 years early
    September 26, 2019
    Amazon has ordered 100,000 new electric vehicles (EVs) as part of The Climate Pledge, a commitment which calls on signatories to be net zero carbon by 2040 – a decade ahead of the Paris Agreement. Companies signing the pledge agree to measure and report greenhouse gas emissions on a regular basis, implement decarbonisation strategies in line with the Paris Agreement and neutralise remaining emissions with additional offsets to achieve net zero annual carbon emissions. Amazon’s founder Jeff Bezos says: “
  • 'Bolder policies needed on electric cars’ says Baringa Partners
    March 9, 2017
    Specialist management consultancy Baringa Partners has responded to the UK Chancellor’s Budget announcement of support for electric vehicles, saying it is a positive first step but doesn’t go far enough. Senior consultant Natalie Bird says the transport sector trails the energy and industrial sectors on decarbonisation. Despite significant uptake in electric cars since 2011, the rate of eligible vehicle registrations slowed substantially last year. Although the UK’s 2050 Greenhouse Gas target theoretical
  • New York mayor to reduce city’s vehicle fleet
    April 11, 2019
    New York’s mayor Bill de Blasio has signed an executive order to reduce the city’s on-road public sector vehicle fleet. The move is part of a commitment to reduce emissions by 80% by 2050. The city will remove 1,000 vehicles from its fleet by June 2021 and reduce the number of take-home vehicles by at least 500. Additionally, it will replace at least 350 SUVs with electric plug-in sedans and promote greater vehicle efficiency by using advanced data collection. “Eliminating unnecessary vehicles fro