Research finds LED stop signs effect ‘similar to normal stop signs’

The results of a two-pronged investigation by researchers from the Minnesota Traffic Observatory at the US University of Minnesota on the safety related effects of flashing LED stop signs have just been released. They conducted two studies: a statistical study to compare the crash frequency after installation of a flashing LED stop signs at 15 intersections to a prediction of what that crash frequency would have been had the flashing LED stop signs not been installed; and a field study using video to exa
February 5, 2014 Read time: 2 mins
The results of a two-pronged investigation by researchers from the Minnesota Traffic Observatory at the US 584 University of Minnesota on the safety related effects of flashing LED stop signs have just been released.

They conducted two studies: a statistical study to compare the crash frequency after installation of a flashing LED stop signs at 15 intersections to a prediction of what that crash frequency would have been had the flashing LED stop signs not been installed; and a field study using video to examine the behaviour of drivers approaching a stop-controlled intersection before and after the installation of a flashing LED stop sign.

The statistical study estimated the reduction in crashes at about 41.5 per cent, but with 95 per cent confidence this reduction could be anywhere between 0 per cent and 70.8 per cent. The conclusion was that installation of the flashing LED stop signs reduced the frequency of angle crashes but that the magnitude of this reduction was uncertain.

The field study found that before installation of the LED stop sign, there appeared to be no change in the relative proportion of clear stops versus clear non-stops when minor approach drivers did not face opposing traffic, but after installation of the flashing LED stop sign the relative proportion of clear stops increased for drivers who did encounter opposing traffic

The group came to the final conclusion that, although qualified by the relatively small sample sizes and wide confidence intervals, a reasonable interpretation is that flashing LED stop signs appear to have an effect similar to that of stop sign-mounted beacon.
Air Quality & Weather Systems Urban Traffic Control

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Norwegian study indicates benefits of average speed enforcement
    November 4, 2014
    Evaluation of the crash effects of section control, or average speed enforcement, carried out at 14 sites in Norway has found a reduction of the number of injury crashes by between 12 and 22 per cent and a statistically significant reduction of the number of killed or severely injured road users (KSI) by between 49 and 54 per cent. Each section control site consists of a stretch or road between two speed cameras (four speed cameras at sites with bidirectional section control), both of which take pictures
    Read More
  • Report: 'Red-light cameras have reduced crashes’
    February 27, 2013
    From the beginning, the SafeLight and SafeSpeed programs in the Louisiana city of Lafayette have met with controversy and resistance. However, a newly released report shows that the programs, which began in 2007, have reduced crashes at monitored intersections and improved the city's finances. A new contract with Redflex, the company that runs the program, will provide cameras at four new locations and will deploy two more speed vans by 2016. “We believe that SafeLight and SafeSpeed, the so-called red-light
    Read More
  • Is road user charging the first stop for congestion management?
    July 23, 2012
    David Hytch, Information Systems Director at the Greater Manchester Public Transport Executive, considers just where congestion pricing schemes should sit in transport planners' hierarchy of options for managing demand. On the face of it, Greater Manchester in England's proposed congestion charging scheme hit just about every sweet spot possible when it came to convincing the general public of the need for and benefits of such a venture. There was the promise from national government of almost £3bn-worth of
    Read More
  • The red light camera choice: 60 killed or save US$231 million a year
    June 5, 2015
    David Crawford investigates new cost-benefit analysis of red light cameras. US states can now realistically calculate the economic benefits of using red light safety cameras, alone or in combination with other measures, to cut road traffic accident levels. The results could be of material value in making the case for the cameras as a number of state legislatures continue to debate their acceptability.
    Read More

Highlighted Content