Skip to main content

Traffic roundabouts, a steep learning curve

Drivers in the UK are very familiar with the concept of traffic roundabouts at intersections, which are designed to keep traffic moving more efficiently than a traditional signal-controlled intersection. However, according to a report on the US Government Executive website, drivers in some parts of the US don’t understand them. In Oakland County, just outside Detroit, some roundabouts have seen big spikes in crashes and property damage since they were built, but the severity of those accidents has been
October 1, 2014 Read time: 2 mins
Drivers in the UK are very familiar with the concept of traffic roundabouts at intersections, which are designed to keep traffic moving more efficiently than a traditional signal-controlled intersection.  However, according to a report on the US Government Executive website, drivers in some parts of the US don’t understand them.

In Oakland County, just outside Detroit, some roundabouts have seen big spikes in crashes and property damage since they were built, but the severity of those accidents has been limited due to a roundabout’s slow-speed design.

“We still struggle to educate motorists with how to properly use a roundabout,” Craig Bryson, spokesman for the road commission for Oakland County, said. “We had hoped the learning curve would be quicker, I guess. But it is a learning curve. It takes some time.”

States have now resorted to producing educational videos to help drivers navigate reconfigures road junctions. A video produced for Oakland County is now being used in Sarasota County, Florida and the 375 Texas Department of Transportation and El Paso County, Colorado, released new roundabout educational videos.

In the event that videos don’t work, states can always use the approach adopted by the 2103 Minnesota Department of Transportation, which hosted a roundabout educational outreach effort at a shopping mall, using a large rubber mat with lane markings and signs leading up to and inside a roundabout. This allowed people to walk through the movements they would make if they were driving a car. A table model with Matchbox cars to push around was also on hand.

Roundabout confusion isn’t just a problem for some US motorists. Japan has experienced similar problems with the implementation of roundabouts as part of a pilot project. At least no one has to navigate the ‘Magic Roundabout’ in Swindon, UK, which combines two roundabouts in one - the first the conventional, clockwise variety and the second, which revolves inside the first, sending traffic anti-clockwise.

Related Content

  • November 27, 2013
    Advanced Driver Assistance Systems: a solution or another problem?
    Do Advanced Driver Assistance Systems represent a positive step forward for safety, or something of a safety risk? Jason Barnes discusses the issue with leading industry figures. Advanced Driver Assistance Systems (ADAS) are already common. Anti-lock brakes or electronic stability control are well understood and are either fitted as standard or frequently requested by new vehicle buyers. More advanced ADAS features are appearing on many top-end vehicles and the trickle-down has already started. Adaptive
  • December 6, 2012
    Debating the future of in-vehicle systems
    Industry experts talk to Jason Barnes about the legislative situation of current and future in-vehicle systems. Articles about technology development can have a tendency to reference Moore’s Law with almost indecent regularity and haste but the fact remains that despite predictions of slow-down or plateauing, the pace remains unrelenting. That juxtaposes with a common tendency within the ITS industry: to concentrate on the technology and assume that much else – legislation, business cases and so on – will m
  • May 8, 2015
    Low-costs solutions to improve pedestrian safety
    David Crawford welcomes low-cost safety initiatives for pedestrians in America. Some 10 people die each week in accidents on crosswalks in the US, that’s more than 10% of all pedestrian fatalities in road traffic incidents - the number of which is running at a five-year high. Ensuring crosswalks are safe is key in supporting the growing enthusiasm for walking as a travel mode. In the last decade of the 20th century, numbers walking to work in the US fell by 26%; while, as recently as 2012, Americans were e
  • January 14, 2022
    No compromise on workzone safety
    The National Work Zone Memorial is a sobering reminder of the dangers of working on US highways. More accurate and timely information can help reduce risks, explains One.network’s Simon Topp