Skip to main content

Smart motorways need review, says coroner

Call follows deaths of two crashed motorists who had no hard shoulder to wait on
By Adam Hill January 20, 2021 Read time: 1 min
Smart motorways are designed to have no hard shoulder (© Clive Stapleton | Dreamstime.com)

A coroner in England has said that smart motorways - which are typically four-lane highways with no hard shoulder - carry "an ongoing risk of future deaths".

Recording a verdict of unlawful killing, coroner David Urpeth is writing to Highways England, which runs the major road network, and to the UK transport secretary, to request a review after an inquest heard that two deaths might have been avoided - if a hard shoulder were available.

Jason Mercer and Alexandru Murgeanu were killed when a truck hit their vehicles on a stretch of the M1 near Sheffield in June 2019.

The two men had been involved in a minor crash and were waiting for assistance.

Smart motorways were introduced in England with the rationale that employing the hard shoulder would help deal with increased traffic without the need for massively disruptive and expensive infrastructure changes.

However, a review by the UK government last year conceded that there are safety concerns - something which road safety campaigners had long suggested.

 

UTC

Related Content

  • September 13, 2019
    UK organisations disagree on smart motorway ‘dangers’
    A spat over how dangerous the UK’s all lane running (ALR) or ‘smart’ motorways are has broken out between Highways England and a leading motoring organisation. Smart motorways do not have hard shoulders, instead relying on emergency areas at intervals to provide refuge for stranded motorists. The AA recently highlighted Stationary Vehicle Detection, a Highways England report published in March 2016, which looks at how long it takes to identify a vehicle broken down in a live lane of smart motorway when s
  • March 1, 2013
    Traffic monitoring and hard shoulder running
    Hard shoulder running is on the increase – and the detection and monitoring of incidents on affected roads is occupying the minds of experts across Europe and the US
  • April 8, 2014
    UK defaults to hard shoulder running to expand motorway capacity
    Hard shoulder running has become the UK’s default response to increasing motorway capacity as Colin Sowman reports. Facing a predicted 46% increase in traffic levels by 2040 and the current economic recovery leading to more people travelling to, from and for work leaves the UK government under short- and long-term pressure to increase the capacity on the main motorway network. Particular sections of motorways are already experiencing repeated, sometimes tidal, congestion and both tight Treasury limits and t
  • February 20, 2025
    Legal streetfight brews as Trump 'saves' New York from congestion charge
    MTA lawyers challenge USDoT move to shut down Manhattan toll scheme