Skip to main content

FEMA and Dutch motorcyclists question Tesla’s type approval

Dutch motorcyclists’ organisations Motorrijders Actie Groep (MAG), the Koninklijke Nederlandse Motorrijders Vereniging (KNMV) and Federation of European Motorcyclists’ Associations (FEMA) have written to RDW, the Netherlands Vehicle Authority, to express their concerns about the way car manufacturers implement driver assist systems. According to FEMA, crashes, studies and evasive answers to its questions FEMA indicate that these systems are not properly tested and certainly not with motorcycles. FEMA
October 19, 2016 Read time: 3 mins
Dutch motorcyclists’ organisations Motorrijders Actie Groep (MAG), the Koninklijke Nederlandse Motorrijders Vereniging (KNMV) and Federation of European Motorcyclists’ Associations (4764 FEMA) have written to RDW, the Netherlands Vehicle Authority, to express their concerns about the way car manufacturers implement driver assist systems.

According to FEMA, crashes, studies and evasive answers to its questions FEMA indicate that these systems are not properly tested and certainly not with motorcycles.
 
FEMA says that a report published in April 2016 by the European Transport Safety Council (ETSC) in which the risks of insufficient tested autonomous systems and over-the-air software updates were discussed. It also stated: “there is an urgent need to put in place certain prerequisites prior to the wider deployment of automated vehicles in Europe”.
 
FEMA, MAG and KNMV claim that a recent crash in Norway involving a young female motorcyclist, a Tesla using Autopilot and two other cars indicated that motorcyclists have a reason to be worried. They say this was confirmed by tests that were performed by the German organisation BASt, which lead to the conclusion that the Tesla system is potentially dangerous in traffic, and by a recent letter in which the German Kraftfahrt-Bundesamt (KBA) requested Tesla to stop using the expression ‘autopilot’, because it is misleading.

The California Department of Motor Vehicles (DMV) has formally issued a draft regulation that demands Tesla cease and desist from using the terms ‘self-driving’, ‘automated’, or ‘autopilot’ when it comes to advertising its vehicles, unless they are capable of driving themselves without any human backup.

The European vehicle type approval for Tesla is issued by the Dutch RDW; FEMA, KNMV and MAG have requested measures to ensure that all two-wheel vehicles can use European roads without being endangered by a malfunctioning Tesla or other vehicle with a poorly tested automatic emergency breaking system.

They have sent questions to RDW about the testing of autonomous vehicles with two-wheelers and have demanded that no vehicles are allowed on European roads that are not properly tested - and tested with all kind of two-wheelers, including motorcycles. A copy of the letter to RDW has also been sent to the Dutch minister of transport and the Dutch parliament.

Dolf Willigers, general secretary of FEMA, commented: “It cannot be that motorcyclists have to fear for their life because car manufacturers skip (part of) the testing phase in an attempt to outrun their competitors, or that our children cannot cycle to school anymore because unreliable car driver assist systems are allowed on public roads for political reasons.  We really have to stop this.”

Related Content

  • December 1, 2016
    Europe to test autonomous cars with motorcycles
    Following a letter written by motorcyclists’ organisations Federation of European Motorcyclists' Associations (FEMA), MAG NL and KNMV sent to the Netherlands Vehicle Authority RDW, expressing concerns about European type approval for Tesla, vehicle authorities will cooperate with motorcyclists’ organisations and conduct their own test program with different brands of semi-autonomous cars. A driver of a Tesla – and of an increasing number of advanced cars – can leave key actions to the vehicle, while in t
  • April 4, 2012
    Powered two-wheelers and ITS
    FEMA, the Federation of European Motorcycle Associations, has produced a special newsletter devoted to powered two-wheelers and ITS, by opening for the first time its pages to a panel of experts from across the field: top researchers in behavioural science and safety systems, members of the motorcycle industry, and officials from the European Commission in charge of transport and information technology. Together, they provide an in-depth insight to the best way forward to bring about a safer traffic environ
  • July 29, 2016
    Ignoring deadly defects in autonomous cars serves no one, say auto safety advocates
    The US Center for Auto Safety, Consumer Watchdog and former National Highway Traffic Administration (NHTSA) administrator Joan Claybrook have told NHTSA administrator Mark Rosekind that "you inexcusably are rushing full speed ahead" to promote the deployment of self-driving robot car technology instead of developing adequate safety standards "crucial to ensuring imperfect technologies do not kill people by being introduced into vehicles before the technology matures." In a letter to Rosekind in response
  • April 18, 2012
    European Parliament hosts exhibition of motorcyclist-friendly crash barriers
    An exhibition that will address the broader issue of the hazard that standard guardrails create for motorcyclists is being hosted next week by Members of the European Parliament Corien Wortmann-Kool (The Netherlands) and Ines Ayala-Sender (Spain). “Safe roadside barriers for motorcyclists” being held from 23-25 April, will showcase a prototype friendly road restraint system, designed to offer better protection for motorcyclists. Current standard European roadside barriers (EN 1317) have not been designed n