Skip to main content

German transport minister clashed with EUI over road tolls

During a visit to Brussels on 12 January, German Transport Minister, Alexander Dobrindt criticised the European Commission's infringement procedure against the German road tolls, expected to be introduced in 2017, reports EurActiv. “I'll tell Ms Bulc that her vision for an EU toll system, that clearly serves to burden German car drivers more, could break the German system. I have no support whatsoever for that proposal,” Dobrindt said of EU Transport Commissioner Violeta Bulc's recent comments about the con
January 15, 2016 Read time: 3 mins
During a visit to Brussels on 12 January, German Transport Minister, Alexander Dobrindt criticised the European Commission's infringement procedure against the German road tolls, expected to be introduced in 2017, reports EurActiv.

“I'll tell Ms Bulc that her vision for an EU toll system, that clearly serves to burden German car drivers more, could break the German system. I have no support whatsoever for that proposal,” Dobrindt said of EU Transport Commissioner Violeta Bulc's recent comments about the controversial tolls.

Bulc has called for a new, voluntary EU-wide toll system. She told German daily Die Welt last week, “There should be no discrimination based on nationality.”

Brussels expects more support from Berlin for a Europe-wide toll scheme, says EurActiv Germany. Transport Commissioner Violeta Bulc wants to put an end to the EU's various toll schemes and has rejected German Minister for Transport Alexander Dobrindt's proposed plans on the matter. According to Berlin's plans, Germans would receive discounts when using the country’s tolled roadways. This has been rejected by the Commission in the past, which cited unacceptable discrimination against non-German citizens.

Bulc told Die Welt that it is possible that the European Commission will present proposals this year that could serve "as the basis for a European toll system for trucks and cars".

Therefore, EU member states that have opted to toll their roadways would be organised into one single system. "I invite Germany to support us in this proposal," said Bulc.

"We need a European solution for road charges," she continued, adding that, "Many different toll systems are a barrier to mobility within the internal market."

On 10 December, the Commission sent the German transport ministry a request for more details about its road tolls to determine whether the new law discriminates against drivers from outside Germany. Germany has until 10 February to respond.

“We expect that there won't be any more delays from the Commission for the German infrastructure levy,” Dobrindt said, using the euphemism he coined for the tolls.

“We know the German infrastructure levy is compliant with EU law. If the European Commission has doubts about that, then the decision has to be taken by the European Court of Justice and the decision should be made fast without any further delay,” he added.

Related Content

  • Extra enforcement key to cutting road casualties in The Netherlands
    November 27, 2013
    While The Netherlands already has some of the safest roads in the world it has ambitious plans to make them safer still, as Jon Masters discovers. In virtually all periodical studies and comparisons of countries’ road safety performance, the Netherlands is consistently in the top three and often leads the world, depending on how casualty figures are compared. According to the International Traffic Safety Data & Analysis Group (IRTAD) of the International Transport Forum, road deaths per capita have falle
  • EU citizens ‘pay twenty times too much for traffic noise reduction’
    November 8, 2013
    According to Paul de Vos, strategic advisor at engineering and consultancy firm Royal HaskoningDHV, European policy forces local authorities to make huge investments in traffic noise reduction. Until 2017, European governments will be spending US$168 billion for noise barriers, quieter roads and measures related to the negative effects of traffic noise, including damage to health. However, by simply making cars quieter, the total cost to the taxpayer could be reduced by a factor of twenty.
  • Remove 80 per cent of traffic lights to boost economy and road safety, says IEA report
    January 26, 2016
    In a new report, authors Martin Cassini and Richard Wellings of the UK Institute of Economic Affairs demonstrate what they say are the negative social and economic effects of the government’s traffic management strategy, and argue for policies that harness voluntary cooperation among road-users. Using case-studies from around Britain, in conjunction with evidence from successful schemes in both Holland and Germany, they estimate that approximately 80 per cent of traffic lights could be ripped out in the UK.
  • Vitronic to supply Netherlands truck toll observation system
    July 12, 2024
    From 2026, truck owners will pay a fee based on kilometres driven on highways