Skip to main content

German road toll deal ‘paves the way for Europe-wide tolling’

The European Union has finally agreed to Germany’s plan to introduce road tolls, says EurActiv, despite originally saying that the proposals were discriminatory to foreign drivers and would break EU law. Germany will now change its road toll law so that it does not discriminate against drivers registered in other EU countries, German Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt said. However, the plan has met with opposition from Germany’s neighbours in the Netherlands, Belgium, Austria and Denmark. Aust
December 2, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
The European Union has finally agreed to Germany’s plan to introduce road tolls, says EurActiv, despite originally saying that the proposals were discriminatory to foreign drivers and would break EU law.

Germany will now change its road toll law so that it does not discriminate against drivers registered in other EU countries, German Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt said.

However, the plan has met with opposition from Germany’s neighbours in the Netherlands, Belgium, Austria and Denmark.

Austria’s Transport Minister Jörg Leichtfried said “the discrimination is now a bit more hidden” but is still there. German social democrats also criticised the deal.

Michael Cramer, German Green MEP and chair of the European Parliament’s transport committee, called the agreement an “unpleasant compromise”. “In the end, only foreign drivers will have to shell out the toll. This is anti-European and will provoke lawsuits before the European Court of Justice,” he said.

Violeta Bulc, the EU transport commissioner said the deal will pave the way for a European-wide road tolling scheme next year and insisted that it will not conflict with her plans to overhaul EU road toll rules early next year. She plans to propose a new law by April to shake up toll rules, digitise toll systems and charge drivers different rates based on how much pollution their cars produce.

Bulc is still deciding between toll rules that are either based on how long cars spend on the road or how far they drive. She has previously said she favours a system that charges based on how many kilometres a vehicle drives and not the number of days spent in a country. Environmental groups have pushed for an EU-wide system that charges based on distance because it could incentivise drivers to use their vehicles less.

Related Content

  • HeERO - harmonising e-Call across Europe
    March 1, 2013
    The second stage of the EC’s HeERO project, which aims to address some of the issues surrounding the eCall system, has just got underway. Jason Barnes reports. As the European Commission (EC)’s Har­monised eCall European Pilot (HeERO) project progresses into its second stage, ‘HeERO 2’, significant progress has already been made in addressing the technological and institutional issues relating to the pan-European deployment of an eCall system based around the new ‘112’ universal emergency telephone number.
  • Avoiding a tangle
    September 4, 2018
    The ITS industry will get into a ‘terrific mess’ if it doesn’t sort out the question of interoperability, says Georg Kapsch. He talks to Alan Dron about data, connectivity – and why governments should stay out of technology issues Governments should set a regulatory framework to help shape the direction of road technologies - but then stand aside and allow industry to create the necessary technologies, according to a European pioneer in the field. Georg Kapsch, CEO of Kapsch Group and Kapsch TrafficCom,
  • Carrots are proving cost-effective in Netherlands
    October 3, 2018
    There are lessons to be learned from congestion avoidance schemes in the Netherlands. David Crawford welcomes some new thinking in road pricing. Highway operators worldwide are being urged to learn from Dutch experience in using financial carrots rather than sticks to encourage drivers to avoid contributing to congestion. A Netherlands/UK group makes a convincing cost/benefit case in a new global survey of road pricing technologies, economics and acceptability. Representing the Rijkswaterstaat section of
  • EU reinforces commitment to C-ITS
    December 13, 2016
    The European Commission, the Innovation and Networks Executive Agency (INEA) and beneficiaries from the C-ROADS have agreed to support seven C-ROADS Cooperative Intelligent Transport Systems, C-ITS) projects with a combined US$58.4 million (€55 million) grant from the EU. This will implement C-ITS services in eight countries (Austria, Belgium, the Czech Republic, Germany, France, the Netherlands, Slovenia and the UK). The projects are part of those supported by the EU under the Connecting Europe Facili