Skip to main content

ITS America: FCC's 5.9 GHz plan is 'reckless'

Allocating part of spectrum from transport safety to WiFi is 'shortsighted and detrimental'
By Adam Hill November 3, 2020 Read time: 2 mins
5.9 GHz spectrum: a battleground for ITS (© Fernando Cortés | Dreamstime.com)

ITS America president & CEO Shailen Bhatt has dismissed the Federal Communications Commission (FCC)'s 'reckless' plans for the 5.9 GHz safety spectrum.

FCC chairman Ajit Pai announced that draft new rules for the 5.9 GHz band "would  make new spectrum available for unlicensed services such as WiFi and finally fulfill the band’s decades-old promise of improving automotive safety".  

FCC also wants to give up on what it calls "long-stalled" dedicated short-range communications (DSRC) technology in favour of cellular Vehicle to Everything (C-V2X).  

“5.9 GHz spectrum has lain fallow for far too long," Pai insisted. 

"For the last two decades, the American people have waited for this prime mid-band spectrum to be put to use, and the time for waiting is over."

But Bhatt strongly disagrees: "ITS America has warned that reallocating the majority of the 5.9 GHz band without fully considering the effects on public safety is reckless."

He suggests that FCC is ignoring transportation safety advice from the US Department of Transportation and state DoTs, as well as a raft of transport and safety organisations.

"While we appreciate the need to allow C-V2X in the band, it is extremely shortsighted and detrimental to the millions of people who travel on US roads every day for the FCC to reallocate 45 MHz of spectrum from transportation safety to unlicensed devices such as WiFi," Bhatt adds.

ITS America will "pursue all available avenues to protect public safety in communities across the country by preventing such action", Bhatt concludes.

FCC says making part of the band available for WiFi is "critical to meeting America’s growing connectivity needs".  

It adds that it will also help improve and expand broadband access in rural America.

FCC's statement continues: "While 5.9 GHz band spectrum has been designated for DSRC for over 20 years, deployment has been painfully slow, and as a result, DSRC has done virtually nothing to improve automotive safety."

"By contrast, C-V2X, is a newer technology that shows great promise, which is why automakers here and around the globe are turning the page on DSRC and moving to implement C-V2X."

FCC will vote on these new rules at its 18 November meeting.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • VTA demonstrating Smart Stop technology at ITS America San Jose
    June 15, 2016
    The Santa Clara Valley Transportation Authority (VTA) is showing conference attendees how its Smart Stop technology can tell bus drivers that someone is waiting at a particular stop, improving the rider experience while saving fuel costs. The Smart Stop demonstration is designed to highlight Vehicle to Infrastructure (V2I) and Vehicle to Vehicle (V2V) solutions using dedicated short range 5.9 GHz Wi-Fi communications. It was built in partnership with Renesas Electronics America, a semiconductor supplier, a
  • ITSA’s Shailen Bhatt looks to the future
    March 6, 2018
    The new boss of ITS America is fizzing with ideas. Shailen Bhatt talks to Adam Hill about the need to rebrand the ITS industry, how technology can leverage tax dollars – and where the Star Wars universe fits in to his philosophy. Shailen Bhatt has a big job on his hands. The CEO and president of the Intelligent Transportation Society of America is the second to hold the post in two years following the resignation last July of his predecessor Regina Hopper. It has not been the easiest time for the
  • Moovit points users to Spin e-scooters 
    August 13, 2021
    E-scooters are expected to provide an alternative to driving cars 
  • Conduent to improve bus lane performance
    April 15, 2021
    System with Hayden AI provides cost-effective enforcement service, Conduent says