Skip to main content

'Phantom’ menace endangers AV passengers, says study 

Projecting a ‘phantom’ image on the road can cause a semi-autonomous vehicle to brake suddenly and endanger passengers, according to a new study. 
By Ben Spencer February 20, 2020 Read time: 2 mins
BGU demonstrates how a phantom image can put passengers in an AV in danger (Source: © Haiyin | Dreamstime.com)

Researchers at Israel’s Ben Gurion University (BGU) say this is because advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS) in semi- or fully-autonomous vehicles (AVs) consider these depthless projections as real objects. 

PhD student Ben Nassi says: “This is not a bug. This is not the result of poor code implementation. This is a fundamental flaw in object detectors that essentially use feature matching for detecting visual objects and were not trained to distinguish between real and fake objects. This type of attack is currently not taken into consideration by the automobile industry.”

The ‘Phantom of the ADAS’ project also showed that attackers can fool a driving assistance system into believing fake road signs are real by distinguishing phantoms for 125 milliseconds in advertisements presented on digital billboards near roads.

He says a shortage of vehicular communication systems which connect cars to each other and the surrounding infrastructure is creating a “validation gap”, which prevents AVs from validating their virtual perception with a third party. 

More alarmingly, Nassi warns that remote attacks do not need to be carried out by skilled hackers who exploit the validation gap as the project demonstrated how such an attack can be carried out by projecting a phantom road sign from a drone. 

BGU researchers are now developing a convolutional neural network model that analyses a detected object’s contextual, surface and reflected light, which is capable of detecting phantoms with high accuracy.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Reversible express lanes and open road tolling combat congestion
    March 2, 2012
    Teri England, Diamond Consulting Services, details the construction of construction of a world first - reversible express lanes with cashless multi-lane ORT - on the Tampa Hillsborough Expressway
  • Is driver information heading for multi-channel mayhem
    October 22, 2013
    Colin Sowman talks to TRL’s research director Dr Alan Stevens about the future for cash-strapped road authorities’ driver information systems.
  • Reliability is key to AV acceptance, finds Dutch study
    August 31, 2018
    Reliability is the key factor in people’s acceptance of autonomous vehicles, suggests a new academic study. Nine out of ten people said it was easy to use 2getthere’s Parkshuttle, operated by the Dutch municipality of Capelle aan den Ijssel. Four out of five respondents said the system - which connects Rivium business park and metro station Kralingse Zoom - is reliable, mainly because of its frequency and punctuality. The qualitative study from Utrecht University also focused on operational factors
  • Here’s why WiM is value for money
    January 23, 2025
    Weigh in Motion systems are not new. What is new is their ability to collect more data and – importantly – more accurate data about axle loading and vehicle weight. Despite the obvious benefits, including safer highways and possibility of automated legal weight enforcement, obstacles remain for faster uptake. David Arminas reports on the manufacturers’ perspective…