Skip to main content

Negative report for road safety cameras

An audit of the state’s speed cameras has found that the Queensland Police Service (QPS) and the Department of Transport and Main Roads (TMR) in Australia have strayed from best practice in using the devices to reduce speeding, with a resultant effect on road safety, according to PSNews online. In his report Road Safety: Traffic Cameras, Acting Auditor-General, Anthony Close found that in the past seven years the QPS had issued 3,760,962 speeding tickets from camera-based evidence, with TMR collecting AU
October 23, 2015 Read time: 3 mins
An audit of the state’s speed cameras has found that the Queensland Police Service (QPS) and the 7026 Department of Transport and Main Roads (TMR) in Australia have strayed from best practice in using the devices to reduce speeding, with a resultant effect on road safety, according to PSNews online.

In his report Road Safety: Traffic Cameras, Acting Auditor-General, Anthony Close found that in the past seven years the QPS had issued 3,760,962 speeding tickets from camera-based evidence, with TMR collecting AU$667.3 million (US$485 million) in fines.

He found the numbers of cameras had grown from 50 mobile, three fixed and 36 red-light cameras in 2008–09 to 100 mobile, 41 fixed, seven combined speed and red-light and 74 red-light cameras and one point-to-point camera system this year.

Close said TMR and the QPS had worked together to combat speeding and disobeying traffic signals through the Camera Detected Offence Program (CDOP), including the use of fixed and mobile speed cameras and red-light cameras.

According to the audit, the CDOP was well designed in its conception, drawing on a strong body of research on effective road safety enforcement.

However, Close said it is not working as well as it could. “This means the frequency and severity of crashes caused by speeding are likely higher than necessary. The two primary aims of the program are to reduce speed-related road trauma and the number of speeding drivers,” he said, commenting that the key issue was getting the right balance between general and specific deterrence.

“The results from road safety research demonstrate that one of the best methods to deter motorists from speeding is by deploying mobile cameras in an unpredictable way across approved mobile camera sites,” Close said.

He claimed the QPS and TMR had acted slowly on known system and process limitations that primarily affected the quality of available data.

According to the audit, this has led to police losing confidence in the mobile camera site scheduling system, resulting in them adopting other approaches to select sites at which to deploy their mobile cameras.

Close said there was a need for stronger program governance to fix the known system and data issues to allow for more timely evaluations and monitoring of the program. He said it was time to implement the program as designed by deploying cameras to the right locations at the right time and mode, which would redress the imbalance between too much specific and not enough general deterrence.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • TISPOL says gig economy tears up enforcement rulebook
    March 4, 2019
    The road safety enforcement sector is facing a crisis. Rulebooks around the world are going to have to change as our roads become a high-pressure workplace for millions of gig economy workers. Geoff Hadwick reports from the TISPOL conference Traffic police forces everywhere will need a fresh approach to regulating the way in which our highways are being used, senior enforcement officers were told at the latest TISPOL European Traffic Police Network annual conference. The World Health Organisation puts it
  • New ANPR solutions overcome variables
    May 18, 2018
    The sheer range of variables makes it difficult to find a single algorithm to ensure a 100% standard of ANPR. David Crawford investigates new processing technology. Automatic number plate recognition (ANPR), using optical character recognition and image-processing to identify vehicles, plays key roles in traffic monitoring and law enforcement, access and parking control, electronic toll collection, vehicle security and crime deterrence. Overall, system performance is well rated, with high levels of
  • No in-road equipment for Queensland's free flow toll bridge
    February 1, 2012
    By May this year, the new Gateway Bridge in Brisbane, which is being built alongside an existing bridge, will be open. With it will come an end-to-end free-flow tolling system. Interview with Sue Caelers, Queensland Motorway Ltd. Queensland Motorways Ltd owns and operates 61km of roadway in the area around Brisbane, Australia. This includes the Gateway Bridge and the Gateway Extension, Logan and Port of Brisbane motorways.
  • Temporary traffic monitoring with Bluetooth and wi-fi
    May 31, 2013
    David Crawford reviews developments in temporary ITS. Widespread take-up of technologies such as Bluetooth and wi-fi are encouraging the emergence of more sophisticated, while still cost effective, ITS responses to the traffic issues posed by temporary road situations such as work zones and special events. Andy Graham of traffic solutions specialists White Willow Consulting says: “A machine-to-machine radio link is far easier and cheaper than reading characters on a plate.” There can be other plusses. Tech