Skip to main content

Houston Police: increase in crashes when red-light safety cameras removed

A new report shows a 30 per cent increase in fatal traffic collisions and a 117 per cent increase in total traffic crashes at 51 intersections in Houston where red-light safety cameras once stood. New figures from the Houston Police Department released by the National Coalition for Safer Roads (NCSR) show total traffic collisions more than doubled from 4,147 in 2006-2010 when cameras were in use to 8,984 in 2010-2014, when cameras were not in operation. The city ended its red-light safety camera program
November 7, 2014 Read time: 2 mins
A new report shows a 30 per cent increase in fatal traffic collisions and a 117 per cent increase in total traffic crashes at 51 intersections in Houston where red-light safety cameras once stood.

New figures from the 1861 Houston Police Department released by the 5755 National Coalition for Safer Roads (NCSR) show total traffic collisions more than doubled from 4,147 in 2006-2010 when cameras were in use to 8,984 in 2010-2014, when cameras were not in operation. The city ended its red-light safety camera program in 2010. During the same time period, fatal crashes rose from 10 to 13, and major crashes rose nearly 85 per cent, from 1,391 to 2,568.

Independent research in Texas and Virginia indicates Houston's experience is not unexpected.

According to the 232 Texas Transportation Institute, in 2010, total intersection crashes increased about 64 per cent, and red-light running crashes occurred three times more frequently in the city of Garland, Texas, after red-light safety cameras were removed.

In Virginia Beach, Virginia, red-light running events increased 11.3 per cent one month after cameras were taken down. With cameras in place, the red-light running rate was 3.1 percent, according to a 2013 study from Old Dominion University.

Reports from other cities further reveal how quickly drivers return to their dangerous red-light running behaviour once camera programs end.

In Kansas City, Missouri, red-light running incidents increased nearly 33 per cent from December 2012 to the same month in 2013, the first month with cameras inactive.

When Pima County, Arizona, ended its speed camera program, the number of drivers speeding more than 11 mph over the posted speed limit increased 1,000 per cent from 2013 to 2014.

When construction work forced the city of Jersey Village, Texas, to remove 10 red-light safety cameras, traffic collisions increased 28 per cent at those locations. Citywide, crashes increased 9 per cent.

"Red-light running is a significant issue in the United States, often contributing to collision-related fatalities," says NCSR president Melissa Wandall.

Related Content

  • New analysis finds speed cameras may create bad driving behaviour
    October 28, 2015
    Using more than one billion miles of driving behaviour data, collected over three years (2011-2014) and including 8,809 separate journeys in 5,353 vehicles, Wunelli, a LexisNexis company, has revealed the most frequent braking black spots across the UK created by speed cameras, based on motorists braking excessively just before speed cameras to avoid being caught. Eighty per cent of all the UK speed cameras investigated had hard braking activity, with braking increasing six fold on average at these loca
  • New South Wales removes speed cameras
    October 3, 2014
    New South Wales Minister for Roads and Freight, Duncan Gay, has announced that speed cameras in ten locations across NSW are to be removed as soon as any safety works such as additional signage, barriers and markings and that work has been finished. Gay said in a statement that the government is keeping to a statement that it made while in opposition, and removing any speed cameras that did not add a proven safety benefit. The 2014 Speed Camera Review of the state’s cameras indicates that early result
  • New York City sees reduction in pedestrian and cyclist fatalities
    July 21, 2017
    New York City has ended the first six months of 2017 with the fewest traffic fatalities ever measured, according to figures released by Mayor Bill de Blasio. Under the Vision Zero program, as of 30 June, the city had recorded 93 fatalities, the first time ever that fewer than 100 lives had been lost in such a period. The full fiscal year ending 30 June recorded 210 fatalities, 31 fewer than the prior fiscal year. The reductions come as the City is increasing traffic enforcement against dangerous violations
  • Low-costs solutions to improve pedestrian safety
    May 8, 2015
    David Crawford welcomes low-cost safety initiatives for pedestrians in America. Some 10 people die each week in accidents on crosswalks in the US, that’s more than 10% of all pedestrian fatalities in road traffic incidents - the number of which is running at a five-year high. Ensuring crosswalks are safe is key in supporting the growing enthusiasm for walking as a travel mode. In the last decade of the 20th century, numbers walking to work in the US fell by 26%; while, as recently as 2012, Americans were e