Skip to main content

Houston Police: increase in crashes when red-light safety cameras removed

A new report shows a 30 per cent increase in fatal traffic collisions and a 117 per cent increase in total traffic crashes at 51 intersections in Houston where red-light safety cameras once stood. New figures from the Houston Police Department released by the National Coalition for Safer Roads (NCSR) show total traffic collisions more than doubled from 4,147 in 2006-2010 when cameras were in use to 8,984 in 2010-2014, when cameras were not in operation. The city ended its red-light safety camera program
November 7, 2014 Read time: 2 mins
A new report shows a 30 per cent increase in fatal traffic collisions and a 117 per cent increase in total traffic crashes at 51 intersections in Houston where red-light safety cameras once stood.

New figures from the 1861 Houston Police Department released by the 5755 National Coalition for Safer Roads (NCSR) show total traffic collisions more than doubled from 4,147 in 2006-2010 when cameras were in use to 8,984 in 2010-2014, when cameras were not in operation. The city ended its red-light safety camera program in 2010. During the same time period, fatal crashes rose from 10 to 13, and major crashes rose nearly 85 per cent, from 1,391 to 2,568.

Independent research in Texas and Virginia indicates Houston's experience is not unexpected.

According to the 232 Texas Transportation Institute, in 2010, total intersection crashes increased about 64 per cent, and red-light running crashes occurred three times more frequently in the city of Garland, Texas, after red-light safety cameras were removed.

In Virginia Beach, Virginia, red-light running events increased 11.3 per cent one month after cameras were taken down. With cameras in place, the red-light running rate was 3.1 percent, according to a 2013 study from Old Dominion University.

Reports from other cities further reveal how quickly drivers return to their dangerous red-light running behaviour once camera programs end.

In Kansas City, Missouri, red-light running incidents increased nearly 33 per cent from December 2012 to the same month in 2013, the first month with cameras inactive.

When Pima County, Arizona, ended its speed camera program, the number of drivers speeding more than 11 mph over the posted speed limit increased 1,000 per cent from 2013 to 2014.

When construction work forced the city of Jersey Village, Texas, to remove 10 red-light safety cameras, traffic collisions increased 28 per cent at those locations. Citywide, crashes increased 9 per cent.

"Red-light running is a significant issue in the United States, often contributing to collision-related fatalities," says NCSR president Melissa Wandall.

Related Content

  • Rethinking urban traffic congestion to put people first
    August 28, 2015
    Following the publication of the Texas A&M Transportation Institute/Inrix report on urban traffic congestion in the US, Robert Puentes, senior fellow with the Brookings Institution’s Metropolitan Policy Program , says that while the focus and themes of the report are largely the same as previous years, big changes are underway in how we study, think about, and address metropolitan traffic congestion. This new, modern approach calls into question whether the endless pursuit of congestion relief makes sense a
  • Cost Benefit: Utah traffic light scheme pays dividends
    March 15, 2019
    A traffic signal control scheme in Utah is being taken up by other US authorities. David Crawford finds out how the Beehive State is leading the way in DoT and driver savings Growing numbers of US state departments of transportation (DoTs) and their road users are gaining real financial benefits from an advanced approach to traffic signal monitoring recently developed in Utah. Central to the system is its use of automated traffic signal performance measures (ATSPM) technology, brought in to improve th
  • IBM and NXP partner on Dutch connected car pilot
    February 21, 2013
    The first results of a smarter traffic pilot, conducted in the Dutch city of Eindhoven by IBM and NXP Semiconductors demonstrate how the connected car automatically shares braking, acceleration and location data that can be analysed by the central traffic authority to identify and resolve road network issues, say the companies. “The trial successfully showed that anonymous information from vehicles can be analysed by local traffic authorities to resolve road network issues faster, reduce congestion and impr
  • Bringing enforcement standards into line
    March 1, 2013
    Difficulties with the apparent accuracy of enforcement systems have been making the headlines in the United States over recent months. Jon Masters investigates the causes and possible cures. Online newspaper reports in the United States over recent months have painted a picture of the authorities struggling to keep on top of their speed and red light enforcement pro­grammes. Among a host of stories put out by the Washington Post and others on the subject of speed cameras during January, there were reports