Skip to main content

Nacto urges NHTSA not to let automakers 'off the hook' on VRU safety

Senior transport leaders want changes to proposed federal rules on vehicle safety ratings
By Adam Hill July 24, 2023 Read time: 2 mins
Big cars: big problems (© Invictus999 | Dreamstime.com)

A group of senior transport leaders in the US is calling on the country's leading safety body to ensure road vehicles are safer for vulnerable road users.

National Association of City Transportation Officials (Nacto) is urging National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA) to change how vehicles are rated for safety.

"Oversized vehicles are making streets deadlier for pedestrians and bike riders," Nacto says. "Proposed federal regulations still let automakers off the hook."

"Under the federal government’s safety rating system, known as the New Car Assessment Program (NCAP), almost every vehicle gets four- or five-star ratings. That’s because the system only takes into account the safety of those within cars, not outside them."

Yet pedestrian deaths are at a 40-year high in the US, with over 7,000 pedestrians killed by drivers each year.

Nacto argues that one of the reasons is that vehicles "are getting bigger and heavier, higher off the ground, and with worse driver sightlines".

NHTSA is proposing the inclusion of a "pedestrian crash worthiness test" as part of NCAP. But Nacto suggests the test would not be included in the vehicle’s final safety rating, "so the vehicles that are most dangerous for pedestrians can still get 5-star ratings".

"The test would also conducted by car manufacturers themselves, and since it’s voluntary, automakers can choose to skip it entirely," Nacto argues. "Even when automakers do participate, they aren’t required to publicly share the results; this crucial information only needs to be published on an obscure website, leaving consumers in the dark."

Public comment on the proposals is open until 25 July.

Related Content

  • IRF executive seminar series - Safer Roads by Design Across Six Continents
    November 9, 2012
    The preliminary programme for the IRF Road Safety Across Six Continents Seminar is now available, and space is limited. The seminar takes place 2-12 December 2012 at Hilton Orlando Lake Buena Vista, Orlando, Florida, USA, and is one of the most comprehensive road safety training programs in the world. Experts from a variety of countries will present best practices and state of the art technologies in roadside safety, work zone safety, vulnerable user safety, traffic management and road safety audits over a
  • Juniper Research: traffic tech will save cities $277bn
    March 2, 2021
    V2X is critical to enhancing smart traffic management services, Juniper Research finds
  • Milesight unveils G2 series for traffic enforcement
    February 19, 2025
    Range includes mobile and enhanced ANPR technologies
  • Intertraffic 2016 programme now online
    March 1, 2016
    The seminar programme for Intertraffic 2016 is now online, including more than 80 theatre sessions, presentations, round tables, workshops and demonstrations. These include topics such as: Launch of Intelligent Public Space; the gateway to smart solutions and applications in public space; Digital Transport paving the way for new chapter in C-ITS; Successfully deploying automated speed enforcement programs; Multimodal Traffic Management - Bridge Management System as well as presentations by manufacturers and