Skip to main content

E-scooter use ‘safer than cars’ in cities: ITF report

Riding an electric scooter in a city is safer for road users than driving a car, according to the International Transport Forum (ITF).
By Adam Hill February 26, 2020 Read time: 2 mins
Electric scooters: not as dangerous as some might think (© Lacheev | Dreamstime.com)

Its new report, Safe Micromobility, defines micromobility as the use of vehicles weighing less than 350kg and with a top speed of 45km/h or less. 

It classifies these into four types, with type A weighing up to to 35 kg and possessing a top speed of no more than 25km/h - which in effect means bicycles, e-bikes and e-scooters.

“A trip by car or by motorcycle in a dense urban area is much more likely to result in the death of a road user – this includes pedestrians – than a trip by a type A micro-vehicle," the report says.

"A modal shift from motor vehicles towards type A micro-vehicles can thus make a city safer."

This would be done by reducing the number of car and motorcycle trips in a city - and potentially increasing the catchment area of public transport by allowing wider access to stations.

That latter finding chimes with another recent report, which said that new forms of mobility must work in tandem with public transit to provide sustainable transportation.

ITF says e-scooter safety "will likely improve once users learn to navigate urban traffic and car drivers become accustomed to novel forms of mobility".

It urges governments to put in place safe cycling infrastructure and "targeted safety regulations for micro-vehicles and shared mobility operations" with traffic calming and protected lanes.

Pedestrians must be kept safe otherwise the number of people walking will fall. To that end, ITF advocates banning micro-vehicles on sidewalks or making them subject to a low, enforced speed limit. 

It also acknowledges that "considerable regulatory challenges exist due to the rapid pace of innovation in micro-vehicle design".

Speed limits for all motor vehicles should be no higher than 30km/h "where motorised vehicles and vulnerable road users share the same space", the report adds.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Europe’s car safety framework needs ‘overhaul’
    March 22, 2016
    Vehicle safety innovations are still benefitting too few road users in Europe due to an over-reliance on a voluntary testing programme rather than regulatory standards, according to a new report by the European Transport Safety Council (ETSC). For almost twenty years, increases in levels of car safety in Europe have been driven mainly by the voluntary Euro NCAP programme which awards the safest cars with a 5-star rating. But according to new data, only around half of new vehicles sold in 2013 had been aw
  • Ito World manifesto calls on cities to embrace MaaS
    September 25, 2018
    Data and alternative transport can combat congestion, pollution and private car dependency in global cities, says Ito World. The UK transit data specialist has published a manifesto which calls on cities to embrace Mobility as a Service (MaaS) to ‘unlock’ their future potential. The MaaS Manifesto: smart data and accessing a city’s potential insists cities also need to have the right infrastructure and ensure the public and private sectors work with emerging players. Ito World says city authorities u
  • C-ITS in Europe: jazz or symphony?
    August 18, 2021
    Communication between vehicles on the road is going to be increasingly important. Richard Lax of Kapsch TrafficCom explains why music is a good guide to the way that this could work safely
  • BMW offers motorcycles built to specific highway duties
    March 26, 2014
    German motorcycle manufacturer BMW is offering bikes built to meet the needs of emergency services. Meanwhile, Dutch firm HSC Nieuw-Vennup can further fine tune the BMW machines to meet specific customer requirements. The new BMW electric scooter now meets German usage regulations and will be available across Europe. This vehicle is well-suited to the needs of urban traffic control duties, offering a range of 100km, a top speed of 120km/h and 0-50km/h acceleration in 2.7 seconds thanks to its 35kW motor.