Skip to main content

Self-driving vehicles ‘may not improve road safety’

Self-driving vehicles are expected to improve road safety, improve the mobility of those who currently cannot use conventional vehicles and reduce emissions. However, a new report by researchers at the University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute (UMTRI) reviews some of the safety aspects attributed to autonomous vehicles and indicates that safety is likely to be an issue as long as self-driving cars share the road with conventional vehicles. Report authors Michael Sivak and Brandon Schoe
January 28, 2015 Read time: 2 mins
Self-driving vehicles are expected to improve road safety, improve the mobility of those who currently cannot use conventional vehicles and reduce emissions.

However, a new report by researchers at the 5647 University of Michigan Transportation Research Institute (UMTRI) reviews some of the safety aspects attributed to autonomous vehicles and indicates that safety is likely to be an issue as long as self-driving cars share the road with conventional vehicles.

Report authors Michael Sivak and Brandon Schoettle looked at current autonomous technology and found shortcomings in its ability to read and predict the flow of traffic, communicate with other drivers and understand urban environments usually acquired "through years of driving experience".

Sivak and Schoettle noted that not all crashes are caused by drivers. Self-driving vehicles could compensate for some but not all crashes caused by other traffic participants, for example a drunk pedestrian stepping suddenly into the roadway.

A small percentage of crashes are also caused by vehicular failures, while roadway and environmental factors such as floods or fog could cause problems.

Although a self-driving car could, in principle, respond faster than a human driver and provide optimal braking performance, it still might not be able to stop in time because of braking limitations.

The report concludes that the expectation of zero fatalities with self-driving vehicles is not realistic, nor is it a foregone conclusion that a self-driving vehicle would ever perform more safely than an experienced, middle-aged driver. During the transition period when conventional and self-driving vehicles would share the road, safety might actually worsen, at least for the conventional vehicles.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Speed cameras yield long-term safety benefits, IIHS study shows
    September 2, 2015
    A speed-camera program in a large community near Washington, DC, has led to long-term changes in driver behaviour and substantial reductions in deaths and injuries, a study by the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety (IIHS) shows. Automated speed enforcement is gradually becoming more common around the country but remains relatively rare, with only 138 jurisdictions operating such programs as of last month. According to IIHS, if all US communities had speed-camera programs like the one IIHS studied in
  • Active traffic management - challenges and benefits
    April 12, 2013
    Minnesota DoT has built one of the most intensive Active Traffic Management (ATM) systems on the road today. Like many ITS deployments, the state has gained benefits but also faces many challenges, as Pete Goldin reports. Smart Lanes is the brand name of Minnesota Department of Transportation’s (MnDoT) ATM system on I-35W in the Twin Cities Metro Area. The original system covered 16 miles of I-35W south of Minneapolis starting in 2009, and was extended by two miles in 2011. Additional ATM equipment was inst
  • In-vehicle systems as enforcement enablers?
    January 30, 2012
    From an enforcement perspective at least, Toyota's recent recalls over problems with accelerator pedal assemblies had a positive outcome in that for the first time a major motor manufacturer outside of the US acknowledged publicly what many have known or suspected for quite a while: that the capability exists within certain car companies to extract data from a vehicle onboard unit which can be used to help ascertain, if not prove outright, just what was happening in the vital seconds up to an accident or cr
  • As US edges to four million road deaths, 'something must change' says GHSA
    February 21, 2024
    'Grim and tragic milestone' requires renewed sense of urgency for road safety action