Skip to main content

Europe’s satellite projects ‘late and over budget’

The French court of Auditors has found that the European satellite navigation programmes, Galileo and EGNOS (the European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service), the European satellite navigation programmes, will cost the EU more than US$14 billion over the period 1994-2020, says Euractiv. The delayed projects were originally allocated a budget of US$5 billion, according to the auditors. Galileo will cost a total of US$11 billion. Half of this amount had already been spent by the end of 2013. The C
February 3, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
The French court of Auditors has found that the European satellite navigation programmes, Galileo and EGNOS (the European Geostationary Navigation Overlay Service), the European satellite navigation programmes, will cost the EU more than US$14 billion over the period 1994-2020, says Euractiv. The delayed projects were originally allocated a budget of US$5 billion, according to the auditors.

Galileo will cost a total of US$11 billion. Half of this amount had already been spent by the end of 2013.

The Court of Auditors blamed this spiralling cost on "a combination of technical setbacks, but also inadequate project management". Equally, the cost of making EGNOS operational, at US$765 million, is double the initial estimate.

When the programme was approved by the Council in 1999, Galileo’s planned date for becoming operational was in 2008. Today, 16 years after its launch, the project is scheduled for completion in 2021; a delay of 13 years. EGNOS, which currently works with the existing American GPS service, suffered six years of delays but was declared operational in 2009.

The Court of Auditors called on Europe to increase efforts to commercialise satellite services at both a national and a European level, to rectify the "modest" promotion of civil applications for the new tool.

"The success of the new European infrastructure relies on the effective promotion of its potential uses, focussing on its advantages compared to GPS (the established American competitor): signal authentication, high accuracy and faster connection times," the auditors stated.

The global market for products and services linked to the satellite navigation is exploding, with growth of up to 30 per cent per year, according to the European Commission. But the existence of GPS as a free competitor, which does not offer a commercial service, has forced the Galileo operators to "reduce their predictions for commercial revenue".

It is currently estimated that 6-7 per cent of the Union's GDP relies on satellite navigation. On top of geo-location applications, satellite navigation systems enable the synchronisation of networks that are essential to the economy (communication, transport, data transmission, etc.).

Galileo will be able to host these applications on either its open (free) service or its commercial service.

Related Content

  • May 29, 2013
    Europe’s EasyWay project accommodates political requirements
    The EasyWay project has evolved to take account of political developments at the European level. By Jason Barnes The European Union’s (EU’s) EasyWay ITS deployment project has its roots in the ambitions of former European Commission President Jacques Delors with regard to truly international networks for energy, information and for transport. Definition of what became known as the Trans-European Transport Network (TEN-T) began back in 1994 with seven working groups. They produced an R&D and policy framework
  • August 1, 2014
    Galileo commercial service on track
    The results of early proof of concept tests (EPOC) carried out by the Authentication and Accurate Location Experimentation with the Commercial Service (AALECS) show that the EPOC team has successfully tracked the encrypted Galileo E6-B and E6-C signals broadcast by Galileo satellites. As a result, the commercial service loop has been closed using both encrypted and non-encrypted signals. The tests are the result of a collective effort involving teams and projects of AALECS, supported by the European Comm
  • December 15, 2016
    Europe’s Galileo navigation system goes live
    After seventeen years and more than US$11 billion (10 billion euros), Europe’s Galileo satellite navigation system is set to go live today, 15 December. Initial services offered free of charge by Galileo include support to emergency services. Anyone placing a distress call from a Galileo-enabled beacon can now be found and rescued more quickly, since the detection time will be reduced to only 10 minutes. This service should be later improved by notifying the sender of the emergency call that he/she has
  • December 5, 2013
    Terrestrial solution to stellar shortcomings
    Inherent weaknesses in satellite communications are leading several countries to re-evaluate terrestrial-based backup systems. There is a tale frequently told in satellite navigation circles, of how landing systems at Newark Airport were disrupted by a truck driver using GPS jamming equipment as he drove along the New Jersey Turnpike. While there was no threat to flight safety as the interference to GPS reference stations being tested, the story highlights how apparently benign threats have the potential t