Skip to main content

Are Detroit OEMs heading towards extinction if Apple acquires Tesla?

Analyst comment from Frost & Sullivan indicates that the business consulting firm believes that Detroit OEMs are in trouble if Apple acquires Tesla and thinks that the rumours surrounding this potential acquisition have some fire behind them. According to automotive and transportation team leader Paraná Tharthiharan: "Apple has an arm that researches automated driving technology and Tesla is also interested in automated driving. Hence, the speculations carry more weight than mere rumours, as if about cel
February 20, 2014 Read time: 3 mins
Analyst comment from 2097 Frost & Sullivan indicates that the business consulting firm believes that Detroit OEMs are in trouble if 493 Apple acquires Tesla and thinks that the rumours surrounding this potential acquisition have some fire behind them.

According to automotive and transportation team leader Paraná Tharthiharan: "Apple has an arm that researches automated driving technology and Tesla is also interested in automated driving. Hence, the speculations carry more weight than mere rumours, as if about celebrities   or   colleagues. The clear trend we expect is the emergence of a smart-phone industry-like value chain that would coexist with the traditional automotive value chain."

With Google already having demonstrated that they can create an 1812 Android in the automotive space with the modified driverless 1686 Toyota Prius, Apple would need its version of an iCar in order to compete and Tesla is considered the technological equivalent of Apple in the automotive world.

Are Silicon Valley giants looking to step into the role of an integrated mobility provider, where automakers end up supplying hardware to these brands, or that of a supplier, so that a 1731 BMW or a 1656 Porsche can best tap the connected-car potential? They cannot step on anyone’s toes, but these potential disruptors hold less potential to replace an OEM or a supplier, but could completely transform the ‘power’ equation in the value chain.

"The future lies in creating smart mobility concepts for Gen Y and the millennials, who do not place great weight on car ownership. They form a huge addressable market base: some of them with driving licences and some without,” said Tharthiharan.  "This  matters, as it defines whether these people  would  prefer  to ever drive at all, or would hand over the driving responsibility to someone else or, in fact, something else."

Bearing in mind that mobile phone users prefer owning the latest iPhone or other  smart-phone  and  place  an emphasis on branding, if  the  future  holds  potential  for cars to be available to one and all, without  having  to own the vehicle, Tharthiharan thinks the future is likely to be brand-driven. "Car makers need to understand this and work on their branding, rather than clinging on to their traditional approach," he says.

In  a  debate  between  brand-image  and heritage, Frost & Sullivan expects brand-image  to  emerge  as  a  clear winner. "We foresee a future day when consumers   provide   an   automotive context to PC versus Mac,” said Tharthiharan.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • Electric minicabs to debut in London
    October 25, 2012
    Chinese electric car manufacturer BYD and London green minicab company greentomatocars have signed a Memorandum of Understanding to create London’s first fleet of all-electric minicabs. BYD will supply greentomatocars with 50 of its pure electric e6 models for trial use in the capital. The cars are expected to be available for customers to use from the second quarter of 2013.
  • Honda and Waymo in discussions on self-driving technology
    December 22, 2016
    Honda R&D the R&D subsidiary of Honda Motor is entering into formal discussions with Alphabet’s Waymo, with a view to integrating its self-driving technology with Honda vehicles. This technical collaboration between Honda researchers and Waymo's self-driving technology team would allow both companies to learn about the integration of Waymo's fully self-driving sensors, software and computing platform into Honda vehicles. As part of the discussion on technical collaboration, Honda could initially prov
  • Zuora: MaaS comes to the masses
    April 28, 2020
    The shift from ownership to usership in the subscription economy provides opportunities for the whole of the mobility sector for the next decade and beyond, says John Phillips of Zuora
  • IN FOCUS: What Lidar does next
    March 16, 2023
    Automotive, tolling, robotics – outside of traffic, road safety and autonomous vehicles, what applications will move the dial in terms of Lidar during 2023? Quite a few, finds Adam Hill