Tolling is a ‘powerful tool to maintain and manage an infrastructure network’

A regional authority voted this week to eliminate tolls on the Cesar Chavez Border Highway in El Paso. On the same day, Dallas city council rejected plans to build a toll road along the Trinity River. The council's action appears to be the death knell for a toll project that was debated for decades as a way to alleviate congestion along a network of aging, narrow highways.

Meanwhile, from September in South Texas tolls will no longer be collected along the Camino Colombia highway near the border city of Laredo. Local lawmakers had argued commercial truckers and others were using alternate routes as a way to avoid the toll and that it was an impediment to the smooth flow of goods through the region.

While a variety of factors played a part in the elimination of the Texas tolls - Dallas' Trinity toll project in particular was beset by environmental concerns and efforts to establish parkland along the river - state Rep. Joe Pickett says there's an overarching connection.

"The common theme is just toll fatigue," says Pickett, an El Paso Democrat who sits on the House transportation committee. Prior to the recent spate of moves, the last time tolls were eliminated from a Texas roadway was 1977, Pickett said.

"Toll roads are designed to be in perpetuity now," he said, arguing that they too often lead to transportation authorities that operate toll roads but grow into bureaucratic behemoths.

Transportation experts say that a primary reason for a growing reliance on tolls is that for far too long Congress hasn't adequately funded the country's transportation needs. The states have traditionally been averse to imposing new taxes or fees to finance infrastructure beyond general upkeep.

"When it comes to funding and financing, states are looking at all kinds of options," said Tony Dorsey, spokesman for the 4944 American Association of State Highway and Transportation Officials. "They're laying out everything on the table, from bonding to loans to public-private partnerships, to sales tax increases like we had in Maryland to gas tax increases that we've seen in several states."

Dorsey says that according to some estimates there's a federal shortfall of US$200 billion in meeting the country's vast transportation needs."The federal government is a partner in this endeavour but it has lagged in giving the states the funding they need to keep up," he said.

A report compiled for the 3804 International Bridge, Tunnel and Turnpike Association noted that in 2014 there were about 5,000 miles of toll roads in the US, a number that could potentially grow to 25,000 miles by 2030 when factoring in express toll lanes and interstates converted to toll roads. Larger states such as Texas, California and Florida tend to have the most toll roads.

In Texas, the Department of Transportation continues to encourage toll projects and an additional 150 miles of tolled or managed-lane projects are in the works, on top of the nearly 700 miles already in place, according to a report this year by the Legislature's House transportation committee.

But the report also is blunt in its assessment, noting that, "There are a handful of tolled projects whose continued existence is not supported by logic. We have debt-free tolled roads, or tolled roads serving no purpose in providing congestion relief or safety enhancements. These should be immediately removed."

Among the recommendations included in the report are that tolls be eliminated once the debt incurred to build a road or highway is retired.

"That's a dumb idea," said Pat Jones, executive director and CEO of the International Bridge, Tunnel and Turnpike Association, adding that tolls are used in a growing number of places to maintain and manage an infrastructure network. "Tolling is a powerful and effective tool for users to pay for the transportation system they use," he continued.

Recent congressional reports have said the country needs to move away from the fuel tax as a funding mechanism and toward direct user fees, he said.

"The smart money in this country is on tolling and on mileage-based user fees," Jones said.