Skip to main content

Study finds support for toll express lanes, less for mileage charges

A new report by the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board (MWCOG) finds that support for a toll managed lanes network grows somewhat the more it is discussed, whereas a vehicle miles travelled charge loses support after discussion. Among 300 people who participated in five-hour moderated small group discussions of alternative ways of dealing with traffic congestion in the Washington DC metro area, toll express lanes on all major highways receiv
September 16, 2013 Read time: 3 mins
A new report by the Metropolitan Washington Council of Governments National Capital Region Transportation Planning Board (MWCOG) finds that support for a toll managed lanes network grows somewhat the more it is discussed, whereas a vehicle miles travelled charge loses support after discussion.

Among 300 people who participated in five-hour moderated small group discussions  of alternative ways of dealing with traffic congestion in the Washington DC metro area, toll express lanes on all major highways received 60 per cent public support versus 10 per cent for a vehicle miles charge.

A third alternative, a congestion charge for entry to central zones had 50 per cent support and 34 per cent opposition. Even supporters thought it wouldn't help much to relieve congestion. Vehicle miles charges were seen by the vast majority as intrusive, ineffectual against congestion and difficult to enforce.

The report says there is wide scepticism about the ability of pricing to reduce traffic and about government’s ability to deliver on promises. The ability of a scheme to raise new revenue is not perceived as a positive since it is a majority view that governments have more than enough money already, but misspend it.

A widespread view that motorists only drive when they have gets in the way of acceptance of congestion pricing and the conclusion is drawn that pricing won't change motorist behaviour.

Toll express lanes, while not seen as a comprehensive solution, are popular for the choice and predictability of travel offered by a managed lanes toll network.
The opportunity toll express lanes offer to improve bus transit service is regarded as a major plus.

The study also found that a vast majority of people agree that congestion is a critical problem. 91 per cent of participants ‘agreed’ or ‘strongly agreed’ that congestion is a critical problem facing the region.

Participants talked a lot about pressures on the road system, saying they feel crowded by too many people and too much development, and that too many people are trying to use the roads.

Scepticism about government competence appears to be root of public unresponsiveness to calls for more revenue for transportation.

The addition of a bus rapid transit (BRT) system or other high-quality transit alternative was also an attractive feature of the scenario. Of all the transportation improvements discussed at the forums, BRT seemed to represent something truly new to many participants and attractive.

Related Content

  • Transit must be accessible to all, says SkedGo
    April 24, 2020
    When it comes to accessibility we need to embrace a more open and collaborative approach to ensure MaaS realises its true potential, says SkedGo’s Sandra Witzel – after all, a billion people on the planet have a disability
  • Open road tolling: safer with less congestion
    January 30, 2012
    Michael J. Davis of PBS&J looks at the positive effect that open road tolling can have on safety
  • Motorists want roads repaired before smart motorways, says survey
    December 5, 2014
    According to research by Bury-based online car supermarket JamJar Direct, which indicates that 47 per cent of Greater Manchester motorists claim to have been affected by the construction works, communications around the M60 smart motorway improvements are sorely lacking. Almost two thirds of Greater Manchester motorists (62 per cent) are aware that the M60 is being turned into a smart motorway, but over 40 per cent, equivalent to 81,000 vehicles per day using affected stretch of M60 between junctions 8 a
  • Upgrading Turkey's tolling system
    April 25, 2013
    A programme modernising road tolling equipment on Turkey’s national highway network has resulted in what is arguably Europe’s most advanced toll system, reports Jon Masters. Turkey has introduced a new system of technology for charging for use of its 2000km national highway network, heralded as the first full-scale use of passive RFID tags for electronic open road tolling in Europe. The new ‘Fast Passing System’ (HGS) is an upgrade of Turkey’s existing Automatic Passing System (OGS) technology, which uses