Skip to main content

Fitch Ratings: ‘Fair’ US interstate tolling can curb highway deficits

According to the latest Fitch Ratings report, a widening gap for the US economy, highway, road and bridge funding deficits, can be curbed by establishing interstate US tolling, providing it is approached fairly and pragmatically. The current tolling framework across the US seems to have no sustainable rationale for the average citizen for why some highways (in states on the east coast and the southeast, for instance) are tolled and some highways (like in many western states) are not. This fosters distrus
February 21, 2017 Read time: 2 mins
According to the latest Fitch Ratings report, a widening gap for the US economy, highway, road and bridge funding deficits, can be curbed by establishing interstate US tolling, providing it is approached fairly and pragmatically.

The current tolling framework across the US seems to have no sustainable rationale for the average citizen for why some highways (in states on the east coast and the southeast, for instance) are tolled and some highways (like in many western states) are not. This fosters distrust which any expansion of tolling must deal with to succeed.

The US highway system accounts for over 47,000 miles of US interstate roads and 17,000 miles of other limited access highways. Despite accounting for less than two per cent of the national roadway network, one-third of total vehicle miles travelled are on these roadways and they need to be maintained and improved.

Fitch managing director Cherian George claims the financial flexibility to implement low to moderate interstate toll rates is considerable without creating meaningful long-term economic risks. Importantly, though, the government will need to change the general public’s perception of interstate tolls as double-taxation. Failure to alter this collective mindset would lead to widespread public opposition that could threaten and ultimately undermine a prospective plan’s success.

As such, numerous economic, social and political factors need to be taken into consideration in order for an interstate tolling program to be successful. “Above all, tolling across highways needs to equitable so that some users do not bear an inordinate share of the cost,” said George.

Related Content

  • August 5, 2013
    Oregon tests new mileage-base charging scheme
    Jack Opiola from D’Artagnan Consulting LLP explains Oregon’s latest moves which mandated a trial of mileage-based road use charging. In 1919, Oregon made the 20th century’s most significant contribution to transportation funding policy, becoming the first state in America to implement a gas tax to pay for roads. This summer Oregon’s Legislature passed, and Governor John Kitzhaber signed into law, Senate Bill 810 which requires a distance-based road usage charge for 5,000 volunteer vehicles by 1 July 2015. T
  • February 1, 2012
    National funding cuts cause fragmentation of US ITS market
    Paul Everett, Research Director with IMS Research, looks at how ITS deployment varies across the US and what this means in terms of market potential for systems manufacturers and suppliers At the end of 2010, the US will have a total resident population of close to 310 million, rising to an estimated 439 million by 2050.
  • December 5, 2014
    Small toll agency adopts big city thinking
    Andrew Bardin Williams looks at a novel option for new toll road authorities. While somewhat politically controversial, outsourcing has gained traction in the business world as a model worth investigating for its efficiency and cost saving benefits. Lean start-ups tend to employ independent contractors instead of full-time employees in an effort to remain flexible and avoid costs associated with pensions, retirement places, health insurance, office space and benefit packages.
  • June 17, 2016
    Joining old and new in Canada’s Highway 407
    David Arminas visits Canada’s Highway 407 ETR to see how the concession is working and hear about new arrangements for the roadway’s extension. The Toronto region is North America’s eighth largest metropolitan area and its roads become notoriously congested. In 1997 Highway 407, a 68km concrete toll motorway which skirts the northern edge of Toronto, was opened and initially operated by the province and CHIC - a consortium of four leading Ontario-based companies. Finance came from the Ontario Financing Auth