Skip to main content

FIA ‘cautious’ about Germany’s road toll scheme

FIA Region 1 has responded to the news that German Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt and European Transport Commissioner Violeta Bulc have reached a deal for a non-discriminatory roll out of a controversial road toll scheme in Germany. Although final details of the deal have yet to be released, FIA Region I cautiously welcomes the deal if it means the replacement of some existing road taxes. The German Minister has committed to earmark revenue from the new road taxation scheme to be re-invested into the
December 5, 2016 Read time: 2 mins
FIA Region 1 has responded to the news that German Transport Minister Alexander Dobrindt and European Transport Commissioner Violeta Bulc have reached a deal for a non-discriminatory roll out of a controversial road toll scheme in Germany. Although final details of the deal have yet to be released, 8054 FIA Region I cautiously welcomes the deal if it means the replacement of some existing road taxes. The German Minister has committed to earmark revenue from the new road taxation scheme to be re-invested into the road infrastructure. European motorists already pay a high level of taxation, covering their costs to the infrastructure at a ratio of 214 per cent.

Jacob Bangsgaard, FIA Region I Director General, said: “European motorists already pay a high level of taxes to use the roads. We hope that the German road toll scheme proposal removes any discrimination against non-Germans. Rather than placing an additional burden on motorists, the Commission and Member State governments should look to the income that is already being generated for better investment into Europe’s road network.”

Some neighbouring countries, such as Austria and the Netherlands still question whether a system that compensates the costs for German nationals and not for foreigners can be non-discriminatory. As the proposal emerges, it will be examined in more detail by FIA Region I and our Mobility Clubs.

Whether or not the scheme will be approved still depends on a vote in the German Parliament, which is unlikely to happen before the upcoming elections. Nevertheless, the Commission seems determined to use this momentum to push forward its goal to add passenger cars to the Eurovignette Directive, thus facilitating Member States to change or increase their taxation of private cars.

Related Content

  • April 24, 2013
    Slow development of Europe's road user charging
    Delegates convened in Brussels for Europe’s 10th annual Road User Charging Conference in March, when both positive and negative developments came to light for advocates of more widespread introduction of RUC. Jon Masters reports. Goings on across Europe in recent months have again demonstrated how very sensitive road user charging (RUC) is politically. At the 10th annual Road User Charging Conference in Brussels at the beginning of March, a Danish delegation was notable for its absence, but Belgian governme
  • March 28, 2017
    Germany’s toll plan could ‘generate US$540 million’
    Germany's Bundestag, the lower house of parliament, has passed a law which would see the introduction of a road toll for cars registered abroad with prices linked to environmental criteria, according to Reuters. Under the toll, cars that pollute less will pay a lower rate. The maximum annual cost for a foreign vehicle would be US$141 (€130). Originally proposed in 2015, the law was disputed by the European Commission and other European countries, which claimed it would be discriminatory towards non-Germ
  • May 16, 2012
    Europe agrees on polluter-pays principle for truck tolls
    EU Member States will in future have the right to apply the polluter-pays principle when setting road tolls on trucks and lorries. They will be able to levy charges for external costs and vary tariffs in order to ease congestion during peak hours and to encourage fleet renewal. Earmarking of revenues for transport infrastructure was the key point of an informal deal reached on Monday evening between Parliament and Council representatives on the revised Eurovignette directive.
  • February 4, 2016
    FIA calls for swift implementation of real driving emissions
    Now that the European Parliament voted to approve legislation to measure real driving emissions (RDE), FIA Region 1 has called for swift implementation and strengthened targets to restore consumer and decision-maker trust. RDE seeks to complement laboratory tests and check whether announced NOx emissions levels are confirmed in real driving conditions. However, the package includes a conformity factor of 2.1 whereby on-road vehicles would be allowed to emit more than twice the official limit from 2017 to