Skip to main content

Norton warns of 'environment without choice'

Autonorama author says driving in US is 'a practical necessity every day for most people'
By Adam Hill August 8, 2022 Read time: 2 mins
Norton: 'We have no idea what people prefer unless they have good alternatives to choose from'

It's vital to make a distinction between the philosophy of transport and technology, insists Peter Norton, associate professor of history in the Department of Engineering and Society at the University of Virginia.

"You can’t skip the philosophy part and go straight to the technology part; that would be like if a physician skipped the diagnosis and went straight to the prescription, which would be disaster,” he says.

In a wide-ranging interview in ITS International, Norton suggests it is possible to reverse the 'transport triangle' - which currently has cars at the top and pedestrians at the bottom, he says - in favour of active travel.

“So right at the top is the automobile, and we know it’s at the top because that’s where the public resources go. And then at the very bottom is walkability - a reversal of the triangle of a century ago when automobiles first flooded American city streets. The right of the pedestrian to walk was regarded as essential and everything else had to work around that. If we can reverse the triangle as we did a century ago, we can reverse it back. And in fact, we can use some of the same techniques.”

Norton, the author of Autonorama, points out: “In most of America, driving is a practical necessity every day for most people – and that’s an environment without choice. Often that is misrepresented as the product of choice, but of course we have no idea what people prefer unless they have good alternatives to choose from.”

Even when there are good alternatives, he says, “it remains difficult once we’ve inherited a mental model in which driving is normal and expected”.

Click here to read the full interview.

The July/August 2022 edition of ITS International is out now.

For more information on companies in this article

Related Content

  • No compromise on workzone safety
    January 14, 2022
    The National Work Zone Memorial is a sobering reminder of the dangers of working on US highways. More accurate and timely information can help reduce risks, explains One.network’s Simon Topp
  • Ertico weaves tunnel visions into the ‘big picture’
    April 7, 2017
    As he takes the wheel at Ertico - ITS Europe, Jacob Bangsgaard talks to ITS International about the challenges and opportunities facing the organisation and the ITS industry. Ertico - ITS Europe’s new CEO, Jacob Bangsgaard, is no stranger to the organisation having spent five years there before moving to the FIA (Federation Internationale de l’Automobile) in 2006. Four years later he became director general of the FIA’s Region I (EMEA), which represents more than 100 mobility clubs, and in 2012 he joined Er
  • Ertico weaves tunnel visions into the ‘big picture’
    April 7, 2017
    As he takes the wheel at Ertico - ITS Europe, Jacob Bangsgaard talks to ITS International about the challenges and opportunities facing the organisation and the ITS industry. Ertico - ITS Europe’s new CEO, Jacob Bangsgaard, is no stranger to the organisation having spent five years there before moving to the FIA (Federation Internationale de l’Automobile) in 2006. Four years later he became director general of the FIA’s Region I (EMEA), which represents more than 100 mobility clubs, and in 2012 he joined Er
  • What's next for traffic management and data collection?
    January 26, 2012
    As the technologies and stakeholders in traffic management evolve, what can we expect to see happening in the coming years? For many, the conversation of the moment is just how, and how far, the newer technologies and services provided principally by the private sector should be allowed to intrude into the realms of traffic management.